Indigenous historians say more than an apology is needed from the Catholic Church
Indigenous historians say more than an apology is needed from the Catholic Church
After the much-anticipated meeting between Pope Francis and a group of Indigenous delegates was postponed due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the delegation is now scheduled to meet with the Pope next week.
Made up of Indigenous elders, residential school survivors, and youth, the group of about 30 delegates is headed to the Vatican in hopes of securing an apology from the Pope for the Catholic Church’s involvement with Canada’s residential schools.
Crystal Gail Fraser, a Gwichya Gwich'in assistant professor in history and native studies at the University of Alberta, said that she’s unsure of what exactly a meeting with the Pope will achieve.
“This meeting is historic, but for me, this expectation of an apology has been long gone,” she told CTVNews.ca in a phone interview. “If an apology was on the table, it would have already happened and I'm not sure, for the broader survivor community in Canada, what this meeting is going to accomplish.”
Various apologies have been made throughout the years by several Canadian churches, politicians, and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. Most notably, former prime minister Stephen Harper apologized on behalf of Canadians for the Indian residential schools system in June of 2008.
“The Government of Canada sincerely apologizes and asks the forgiveness of the Aboriginal peoples of this country for failing them so profoundly,” he said at the time.
Among the 94 calls to action released by Canada’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission in 2015 is an apology from the pope for the Roman Catholic Church’s role in the “spiritual, cultural, emotional, physical, and sexual abuse of First Nations, Inuit, and Metis children in Catholic-run residential schools.” In 2018, however, the Catholic Church issued a letter to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau stating that Pope Francis would not deliver an apology.
Fraser said she realizes that an apology may have great meaning for some Indigenous and intergenerational survivors, particularly for those who are members of the Catholic Church themselves.
“To receive an apology, that is when the healing process can start [and] it can be a marker of the end of grief,” she said. “If this would improve the life or the lives of direct survivors and intergenerational survivors, then I'm definitely supportive of that.”
But she stressed that a meaningful apology must be followed by action.
ACTION THROUGH ACCOUNTABILITY
Daniel Paul, a Mi'kmaq elder and historian, echoed this sentiment. An apology from the Catholic Church for its role in Canada’s residential schools doesn’t go far enough to advance reconciliation with Indigenous peoples, he said.
“I don't think it matters anymore,” he told CTVNews.ca in a phone interview. “There's something more substantial I’d like to see: an apology for the doctrine of discovery and [to] repudiate it.”
Paul is referring to a legal framework established in 1493 that stemmed from a series of papal bulls, or formal statements from the pope. The doctrine of discovery allowed European explorers to claim land as their own, regardless of its original inhabitants.
“It justified the whole project of colonialism and colonization,” Fraser explained.
Fraser, Paul and Indigenous groups are calling for an acknowledgement of the doctrine’s damaging impact on Indigenous peoples, and asking that it be revoked.
“I would like to see the Pope repudiate the doctrine of discovery,” said Paul. “Several Christian denominations have repudiated it, but the document itself belongs to the Pope in Rome.”
Fraser also called on the Catholic Church to honour its legal obligations to compensate survivors through the Indian Residential School Settlement Agreement. In November, it was reported that a ruling handed down in 2015 by a Saskatchewan judge released the Catholic Church from settlement obligations to residential school survivors. The deal excused church groups from making $79 million worth of payments and in-kind services to survivors under the agreement.
Fraser also pointed to a number of Indigenous artifacts currently on display in the Vatican Museums. Part of the path to reconciliation involves returning these items to their owners, she said.
“How are those items being repatriated?” she said. “The Catholic Church does not own those pieces, and in many cases, they may have spiritual or ancestral significance.”
ACCESS TO RESIDENTIAL SCHOOL RECORDS
But perhaps the main form of accountability comes through more transparency around the overall operation of Canada’s residential school system, said Fraser. This includes releasing many more residential school records and making them easier to access, she said.
“I think the reason why we're having this conversation, which is sometimes overlooked or gets lost, is because of the thousands of children who died at Indian residential schools and the unmarked graves,” she said. “We're never going to have the full picture but this archival bit would be so significant to our understanding of what actually happened.”
In October, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told a group of Tk'emlups te Secwepemc leaders, residential school survivors and their families that “all the records in possession of the federal government have already been turned over" to the National Centre for Truth and Reconciliation (NCTR), based in Winnipeg.
The centre, however, said it was still waiting for these records, which include final versions of school narratives and supporting documents assessed for compensation claims stemming from abuse at the institutions. More recently, the federal government announced it had signed a Memorandum of Agreement with the NCTR that outlines how and when it will release thousands more of these residential school records. However, an exact timeline has not been made public.
According to Fraser, many more student deaths are likely to be found in those archival documents. Access to these records and accountability from the church and state regarding their roles in residential schools is key not just in helping community members heal, but forging a true path to reconciliation.
“I'm still going back to this question about accountability…I don't think accountability is simply an apology,” she said. “If somebody came to your home, smashed out all the windows and then said, ‘I'm sorry about that,’ would you still not expect them to replace the windows?
A 'truly innocent' engaged couple was shot dead while attempting to flee their attacker outside their home after a landlord-tenant dispute escalated on Saturday night, according to police.
Farmers in Atlantic Canada are growing increasingly worried about drought, as many regions on the east coast have been classified as drier than usual for this time of year, with little rain in the forecast.
Turkiye President Recep Tayyip Erdogan won reelection Sunday, extending his increasingly authoritarian rule into a third decade in a country reeling from high inflation and the aftermath of an earthquake that levelled entire cities.
Both Smith and Notley agree the vote will be one of the most consequential in decades, featuring two leaders in their 50s who have been both premier and Opposition leader.
The historic impeachment of Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton was just the first round of a Republican brawl over whether to banish one of their own in America's biggest red state after years of criminal accusations.
Less than two months after he pleaded guilty to storming the U.S. Capitol, Texas resident Daniel Goodwyn appeared on Tucker Carlson's then-Fox News show and promoted a website where supporters could donate money to Goodwyn and other rioters whom the site called 'political prisoners.'
Convicted murderer Daniel Jolivet, in prison for the past 30 years, has maintained his innocence since the day he was arrested. W5 reviews the evidence he painstakingly assembled while behind bars.
W5 Producer Shelley Ayres explains how she was in awe to meet what the Guinness Book of World Record's has named the World's Tallest Teenager, a 17-year-old from Quebec who plays for Team Canada.
CTV W5 investigates what authorities knew about plans to smuggle cocaine out of the Dominican Republic on a Toronto-bound Pivot Airlines flight. The airline's crew is demanding justice following their eight-month detention.
Gordie Sampson has written hit songs for some of the biggest names in country music, including Carrie Underwood and Luke Bryan. CTV W5 speaks with the Grammy winner from small-town Nova Scotia about his creative process.
A CTV W5 investigation reveals that a critical shortage of volunteer firefighters in this country is having a potentially deadly impact, especially in rural Canada.
Sandie Rinaldo tells the story of the largest Black military unit in Canadian history, whose members had to fight to serve for Canada in the First World War as they faced rampant racism at home.
Toronto mayoral candidate Olivia Chow continues to lead the pack with less than a month until voters cast their ballot, according to two new polls released on Monday.
A 'truly innocent' engaged couple was shot dead while attempting to flee their attacker outside their home after a landlord-tenant dispute escalated on Saturday night, according to police.
Mayor Mark Sutcliffe and several councillors will outline the 2023 construction season projects during a media conference on Slater Street at 10:30 a.m., including potential traffic impacts.
There was an entire operation set up by the Ottawa Hospital, only steps from the finish line for Tamarack Ottawa Race Weekend with more than 100 health professionals ready for anything that could go wrong this weekend.
More than 200 passengers were stuck on a VIA Rail train near Alexandria, Ont. for several hours Sunday evening, after a mechanical issue stopped the train.
On Tuesday, Minden, Ont. business owners will plead to the Ford government to grant the community a one-year moratorium on the closure ahead of the June 1 planned closure date.
A "community-led" referendum is asking thousands of Ontarians to weigh in on whether the privatization of the province's healthcare system is good for the future.
Rania Mukhtar is still processing her recent trip to Sudan, which was interrupted by the outbreak of military conflict between the Sudanese army and the paramilitary Rapid Support Forces.
Ager Hasan being found guilty of second-degree murder, a Cambridge woman climbing Mount Everest, and free tuition for some First Nations students round out the most-read stories of the week.
A 'truly innocent' engaged couple was shot dead while attempting to flee their attacker outside their home after a landlord-tenant dispute escalated on Saturday night, according to police.
The Ontario Health Coalition started a referendum in April, asking people to choose whether they want public hospital services privatized to for-profit hospitals and clinics.
A change in venue has the Dare 2B Challenged event running in the right direction. 250 people took part in the all-female event Sunday morning at Holiday Beach
A Laval, Que. family says a crosswalk in front of their house is an accident waiting to happen. They say too many cars don't stop, leading them to worry each time their child has to cross the street. "It's as if it's not even there," said resident Chris Horell, who lives near to the intersection of Saint-Martin Blvd W and Dutrisac St.
Two women are dead and three people, including children, are injured after a head-on vehicle crash in Quebec's Eastern Townships on Saturday night. The collision occurred at about 11:45 p.m. near Farnham, about 60 kilometres southeast of Montreal.
With hot weather forecasted across Quebec this week, the province's forest fire agency is advising the public not to light outdoor fires until at least Thursday.
Residents in Point Douglas say their area has become a dumping ground for the rest of the city's unwanted garbage, and want more done to get rid of the piles of trash accumulating in the central-Winnipeg neighbourhood.
Both Smith and Notley agree the vote will be one of the most consequential in decades, featuring two leaders in their 50s who have been both premier and Opposition leader.
Thousands of runners laced up their shoes and toed the line for the 59th annual Calgary Marathon Calgary Marathon on Sunday, including a 92-year-old rookie, a pair of world record setting runners handcuffed to each other, and a Ukrainian runner who paid tribute to her homeland.
After spending some time in Calgary over the weekend, NDP leader Rachel Notley wrapped up her campaign today with two rallies on the way home to Edmonton ahead of election day.
Fire activity in Alberta picked up overnight Saturday, with Alberta Wildfire counting 57 wildfires Sunday afternoon, including 17 which were classified as out of control.
Friends, family and supporters met at the bottom of Walterdale Hill for a walk honouring Lauren Jarvis and to raise money for the Victims of Homicide Support Society.
A survey by Vancouver city staff has concluded that SROs, or single room occupancy buildings — often deemed a last resort for housing — are becoming increasingly unaffordable for those on income assistance.
On Monday, West Vancouver mayor and council will vote on a motion to name a new fitness park after Keen Lau, who drowned while trying to save Labrador Loki from Cypress Creek. And they will hear from Loki’s dog walker Sandra Smith, who is advocating for changes to the creek.
One of the so-called godfathers of artificial intelligence says governments need to move faster on regulations to protect against the dangers of the rapidly advancing technology, before it poses a larger threat to humanity.
With just four weeks left until the House of Commons breaks for the summer, the weekly panel of political strategists on CTV's Question Period says it's likely time for the prime minister to shuffle his cabinet.
Almost a year before the closure of 24 Sussex Drive due to disrepair and an infestation of rodents, the chairman of the National Capital Commission's board of directors warned that further delaying a cabinet decision on the fate of the residence would put the whole structure at risk.
Allergies in both children and adults have definitely been on the rise over the last several years, much of the rise in allergies and asthma 'can be directly linked to climate change,' experts say.
It is a world wrapped in mystery - the seventh planet from the sun, Uranus, seen up close just once nearly four decades ago by a passing NASA probe and still warily guarding its secrets.
Egypt unearthed human and animal mummification workshops as well as two tombs in the ancient burial ground of Saqqara, officials said on Saturday, marking the latest in a string of discoveries that the country hopes can help revive its vital tourism industry.
France confirmed its aim to launch a vaccination program against bird flu in the autumn after results from a series of tests on the vaccination of ducks showed 'satisfactory effectiveness,' the farm ministry said.
Several Jewish groups, politicians and an alliance of civil society groups gathered for a memorial ceremony and a protest rally against a concert by Roger Waters in Frankfurt on Sunday evening.
Dedicated fans of 'Succession' are locking in plans to watch the whopping 88-minute finale while turning online for emotional support, memes and endless theories about how the show could end and who will prevail.
Asian shares are mostly higher after President Joe Biden and House Speaker Kevin McCarthy reached a final agreement on a deal to raise the U.S. national debt ceiling, though the measure requires approval by Congress.
Mortgage delinquencies are expected to rise by more than one-third of current levels over the next year, according to some economists. If you anticipate being unable to make your payments and decide to sell your home, here's what an expert says you should consider.
A new report is casting doubt on the idea that Canada is facing a widespread labour shortage and bolsters the arguments by some labour economists that high job vacancies aren't due to a shortage of workers.
It's a joyous day for Eve, resident falcon at the Université de Montreal: her babies are hatching. The event is being live-streamed on Sunday from a nest box atop the 23rd floor of a tower on campus.
Pajaree Anannarukarn of Thailand capped off the longest week on the LPGA Tour with a 3-and-1 victory Sunday to win the Bank of Hope LPGA Match Play over Ayaka Furue of Japan.
The Toronto Blue Jays took another step toward a turnaround at the end of a rough month, posting their first series win in four ties in well-rounded fashion.
The 24 Hours of Le Mans, the world's most famous endurance race, will be open to hydrogen-powered cars starting in 2026, Pierre Fillon, the president of the Automobile Club de l'Ouest, said Saturday.
A Tennessee company is refusing demands from U.S. regulators to recall millions of vehicles due to airbag inflators that can explode and shoot shrapnel into drivers. While cases are rare, there has been at least one death in Canada, where officials lack the authority to demand a similarly sweeping recall.
Defending Formula One champion Max Verstappen produced a superb final lap to take pole position at the Monaco Grand Prix on Saturday and deny Aston Martin veteran Fernando Alonso his first pole in 11 years.
