Vaccine mandate: How a wrongful dismissal claim could play out
As workplaces enforce their own vaccine mandates — placing their employees on unpaid leave or terminating their employment altogether if they refuse to get vaccinated without a medical exemption — it remains to be seen just how many wrongful dismissal claims will be launched, and whether they will stand up to legal scrutiny.
Although each case will depend on its own set of facts, this has become largely new territory for the lawyers who specialize in this field of law.
CTVNews.ca spoke to three lawyers about what a wrongful dismissal claim could look like as it relates to vaccine mandates, which more than anything may revolve around whether to compensate an employee.
CASES TO DATE
Already, some rulings have been issued related to vaccine policies.
This month, a labour arbitrator dismissed a claim brought by Teamsters Local Union 847 against Maple Leaf Sports and Entertainment after an employee was placed on unpaid leave for refusing to disclose his vaccine status.
An arbitrator this month also ruled in favour of the Power Workers' Union in Ontario after it filed a grievance alleging the Electrical Safety Authority's vaccine policy was unreasonable and a "significant over-reaching" of management rights.
Also this month, an arbitrator dismissed a grievance by United Food and Commercial Workers Canada Local 175 against Bunge Hamilton Canada, concluding the employer's vaccine policy to be "reasonable."
And in November, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice denied a request from Amalgamated Transit Union Local 113 to pause the Toronto Transmit Commission's vaccine policy for up to 60 days.
Lior Samfiru, a national co-managing partner at Samfiru Tumarkin LLP, told CTVNews.ca that his firm has received thousands of questions in recent months about vaccine mandates.
Samfiru, who specializes in labour and employment law and whose firm represents both employees and employers, says the firm has been retained by hundreds of individuals who have been let go because they weren’t vaccinated or were placed on unpaid leaves of absence.
"I can tell you, that right around nearly 20 years of practising law, I have never seen the same issue come up so often and so extensively in such a short period of time," he said.
When it comes to a wrongful dismissal claim, he says it doesn't have much to do with why an employee is let go, but rather on whether compensation is owed.
If an employee is let go without proper, or any, severance, that person is generally considered to have been wrongfully dismissed, regardless of the reason, Samfiru says.
The other aspect to consider is what happens when an employee is put on indefinite unpaid leave.
In those cases, Samfiru says an employee can wait to get called back to work. Otherwise, the individual can treat it as a termination, also known as constructive dismissal, which an employee also would be entitled severance for, he says.
Another factor is whether an employee is unionized or not. A unionized employee would not be allowed to bring a wrongful dismissal claim in civil court and, instead, would have to bring a grievance through his or her union, as it relates to the collective agreement with their employer.
A non-unionized employee, meanwhile, would typically launch a civil action. Certain employees in federally regulated industries, such as air transportation, banks and telecommunications, who aren't unionized also have the right to grieve their case through an unjust dismissal claim under the Canada labour Code, similar to what a unionized employee would proceed through with arbitration.
The situation also would be different if a government mandate exists, Samfiru says, such as one for federally regulated workplaces.
The federal government has said it will require employees in all federally regulated workplaces to be vaccinated against COVID-19, with regulations coming into force in early 2022.
Bill Gale, an employment lawyer and partner at the Toronto firm Grosman Gale Fletcher Hopkins LLP, says when it comes to ensuring the health and safety of employees, he believes a lot of employers are nervous about the potential for lawsuits.
Given the circumstances of the last two years with the pandemic, Gale says he believes judges will be more likely to find these mandates to be reasonable.
But on the issue of severance, he said judges have tended to be fairly protective of "the little guy."
"So I think that part of it, there will be a lot of sympathy for a lot of employees who've lost their jobs," he said.
An employee could be let go without severance, or for cause, if the individual is guilty of serious wrongdoing, such as theft, fraud or gross insubordination or incompetence.
Many employers, Samfiru says, have taken the position that an employee's refusal to get vaccinated is cause.
"It's really about whether or not that employee is owed severance and it's our view, and generally the legal view, that in most cases if an employee is let go because they’re not vaccinated that’s not cause," he said.
Ultimately, the question of whether an employee's refusal to get vaccinated counts as insubordination is what the courts may decide.
"I think that in those types of cases, judges will be reluctant to equate refusal to become vaccinated for cause for dismissal, because then the employee gets nothing," Gale said.
Casey Dockendorff, a partner at Filion Wakely Thorup Angeletti LLP and a lawyer based out of London, Ont., who works on behalf of employers, said just cause can depend on a number of factors.
Was the policy reasonable given the circumstances? Did the employee know about the policy? Was he or she given an opportunity to comply with it? Were warnings issued? Was the employee advised of the consequences for failing to comply?
"That's what a court is going to look for on a straight-up termination," she said.
But in the end, no situation is black and white.
"I think there's no one-size-fits-all approach to this and we'll have to see how this shakes out in the courts," Dockendorff said.
A human rights complaint, which could involve race, religion, sex, place of origin, age and disability, is normally handled by a tribunal, but claims can be brought up in court alongside wrongful dismissal actions.
Specific to vaccines, an employee could claim a medical exemption if a doctor confirms the person would have an adverse reaction to a vaccine.
But on religious or personal beliefs, the question becomes a bit more complicated.
"I'm not aware of a religion that prohibits this type of vaccination as part of its religious dogma, if you will," Gale said.
Dockendorff notes that the Ontario Human Rights Commission (OHRC) took a position on this back in September, stating that while the Ontario Human Rights Code prohibits discrimination based on creed, "personal preferences or singular beliefs do not amount to a creed for the purposes of the Code."
"The OHRC is not aware of any tribunal or court decision that found a singular belief against vaccinations or masks amounted to a creed within the meaning of the Code," the statement reads.
It would also depend on the policy itself and whether it actually makes vaccination mandatory.
“It'll be interesting to see what the courts say with respect to an employer's ability to mandate a particular vaccine, provided that there's exemptions for human rights-related reasons," Dockendorff said.
WHAT COMES NEXT?
Samfiru says most employment matters do settle, often within a few weeks or months, although some vaccine mandate-related cases could head to court by this summer or fall at the earliest.
The issue of compensation would be felt more strongly by small-business owners, who may already be struggling financially and could be liable to pay up to two year's worth of severance per employee.
One issue that may involve the courts as well, he says, is whether a demand for an employee's vaccination status is in fact legal under occupational health and safety legislation.
"I think there's a real argument that it's not legal," he said.
Especially with the Omicron variant so widespread, the success of future cases may depend on what exactly an employer is looking to accomplish with its vaccine policy.
Omicron, while more transmissible, is less likely to result in severe illness or hospitalization compared to the Delta variant, particularly for those who are fully vaccinated, research has shown.
But from an employment standpoint, Samfiru says if a person is at a higher risk of getting Omicron despite being fully vaccinated, it could call into question the justification for certain vaccine mandates.
"I think a lot of employers are implementing these mandates as kind of knee-jerk reactions without actually considering their liability and what they may owe these employees, and it's a problem."
MORE HEALTH NEWS
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Russia sanctions 61 more Canadians, including top Trudeau staffers, premiers, mayors and journalists
Russia has issued a fresh round of sanctions, targeting 61 Canadians including premiers, mayors, journalists, military officials and top staffers in Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's government.
Poilievre defends investments in rental properties while campaigning to address housing affordability
Even as he decries government policies for pushing up the cost of housing, Conservative leadership candidate Pierre Poilievre is defending investments he and his wife made in rental properties of the kind that some economists say contribute to rising real estate prices.
Canadians considering summer travel plans have to factor in COVID-19 restrictions that are in flux around the world, as countries change their rules on masking and border-crossing. CTVNews.ca has compiled a list of the vaccination, COVID-19 testing and masking requirements at some of the most popular vacation destinations for Canadians:
Russian President Vladimir Putin claimed victory in the battle for Mariupol on Thursday, even as he ordered his troops not to take the risk of storming the giant steel plant where the last Ukrainian defenders in the city were holed up.
A resurging interest in travel has seen the number of Canadian passports issued over the past year more than triple, in some cases resulting in longer wait times, the latest figures from the federal government show.
It was no surprise that beloved Antigonish, N.S., taxi driver John MacLellan gave what money he had to the local hospital in his will, family friend Margie Zinck said.
The Ukrainian Canadian Congress says an arson attack on the home of a Ukrainian family in Victoria should be investigated as a hate crime.
Shana Olie says she never thought she'd be stuck in Canada, unable to see her gravely ill father in the U.K. -- not because of the pandemic, but due to administrative delays at Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada.
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis is asking lawmakers to end Disney's government in a move that jeopardizes the symbiotic relationship between the state and company.
Experts say Canada needs to develop a robust system to detect COVID-19 activity in the absence of wide-scale PCR testing. Since the onset of the Omicron variant, provinces and territories have scaled back access to gold-standard PCR testing, citing the lack of capacity to keep up with demand and the need to free up health-care resources.
A product recall has been issued for some Insignia brand air fryers and air fryer ovens over concerns that the units can overheat, posing a potential burn and fire hazard.
A Montrealer is among the five victims of a deadly plane crash in Haiti, according to Quebec Liberal MNA Paule Robitaille.
What's happening in Ukraine on Thursday: Western officials say Ukraine will need economic and military support for months to come as the war grinds into a long conflict.
British lawmakers have ordered a parliamentary investigation into Prime Minister Boris Johnson for allegedly lying about whether he broke coronavirus restrictions by attending illegal gatherings during the pandemic.
France's presidential election will be a rematch of the 2017 contest, when the far right's Marine Le Pen faced off against political newcomer Emmanuel Macron. Macron won that race by nearly two votes to one.
Israel's air force and Palestinian militants traded fire across the Gaza frontier early Thursday as clashes erupted again at Jerusalem's most sensitive holy site, worsening an escalation that has been eerily similar to the lead-up to last year's Israel-Gaza war.
A Metis group from Manitoba say Pope Francis took ownership of the harms of the Roman Catholic Church during a meeting at the Vatican today.
Israel has seen the deadliest string of attacks in years. Its troops have launched arrest raids deep inside the occupied West Bank, triggering gunbattles. Clashes have broken out at a major site in Jerusalem sacred to Jews and Muslims and rockets have been fired from Gaza. Here's a look at how we got here.
Canadian officials, including Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland, joined allies in staging a walkout of a G20 meeting in Washington, D.C. on Wednesday in protest of Russia's involvement.
Russia sanctions 61 more Canadians, including top Trudeau staffers, premiers, mayors and journalists
U.S. health officials have sent out a nationwide alert warning doctors to be on the lookout for symptoms of pediatric hepatitis, possibly linked with a cold virus, as part of a wider probe into unexplained cases of severe liver inflammation in young children.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration is investigating dozens of reports of customers getting ill after eating Lucky Charms cereal, but no Canadian recalls have been issued yet.
A new study has found that women who suffer from long-COVID typically experience more symptoms than their male counterparts.
Pterosaurs ruled the skies during the age of the dinosaurs. Not only did these flying reptiles have feathers, but they could actually control the colour of those feathers on a cellular level to create multicolour plumage in a way similar to modern birds, new research has revealed.
On Jupiter's moon Europa, a saltwater ocean exists deep beneath a thick ice shell. Now, a surprising connection between the ice shell and the Greenland ice sheet on Earth has provided new insight: Europa's ocean may be habitable, according to a new study.
Japanese researchers have developed computerized chopsticks that enhance salty tastes, potentially helping those who need to reduce sodium in their diets.
Attorneys for actor Amber Heard resumed their cross-examination of her ex-husband Johnny Depp in a Virginia courtroom on Thursday, taking aim at his alcohol and drug use as well as texts he sent to a friend about wanting to kill and defile his then-wife.
CNN's brand-new streaming service, CNN+, is shutting down only a month after launch.
With more than 100 films, the 58-year-old Nicolas Cage has long been one of the most particular tastes in movies. Yet by being 'an amateur surrealist,' as he refers to himself, Cage has emerged as one of Hollywood's most widely loved stars.
Elon Musk says he has lined up US$46.5 billion in financing to buy Twitter, putting pressure on the social media platform's board to negotiate a sale deal.
Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. says it expects home sales and the pace of price growth for them will remain elevated this year, but ease from their highs of 2021.
Canada's main stock index was down in late-morning trading, led lower by losses in the base metals sector, while U.S. stock markets moved higher.
A new report has found that 28 per cent of Canadians are experiencing challenges disconnecting from their jobs after regular work hours, a trend experts at LifeWorks say is continuing to impact employees' mental health.
Queen Elizabeth is being honoured with a Barbie doll in her likeness to mark her Platinum Jubilee this year.
From a complete unknown in the speed skating world to a future shining star, Ryan Gibson, 23, is learning the ropes of the sport and aiming for an Olympic debut.
Joel Embiid scored a dagger three-pointer with 0.8 seconds left in overtime to lift the Philadelphia 76ers to a 104-101 victory over the Toronto Raptors on Wednesday, taking a 3-0 lead in their first-round playoff series.
The crowded field to buy Chelsea now features 23-time Grand Slam winner Serena Williams and seven-time Formula One champion Lewis Hamilton.
So much comes out of Tyson Fury's mouth during fight week that it's hard to know which aspects to gloss over and what to take seriously from one of boxing's most colourful and controversial characters.
Ford is recalling more than 650,000 pickup trucks and big SUVs in the U.S. because the windshield wipers can break and fail.
Tesla has posted record profits once again, overcoming supply chain issues that have dogged the broader auto industry to blow away Wall Street's forecast for the company for the first quarter of 2022.
A bike rack on the back of his car cost a Calgary man $162 when he was stopped by police after returning from a cycling trip with his wife.