Springwater residents voice concerns over Barrie’s expansion plans

Barrie’s annexation plan draws mixed reactions in Springwater at public meeting.

Residents packed a public meeting in Springwater Wednesday evening to make their voices heard on Barrie’s controversial proposed boundary expansion into neighbouring townships.

Many in attendance expressed support for Springwater Mayor Jennifer Coughlin, who has faced criticism throughout the talks surrounding Barrie’s plan to take over portions of land in Springwater and Oro-Medonte.

The mayor declined CTV News’ request for comment on the matter.

The City of Barrie is seeking to annex large areas from both townships to accommodate housing growth and, more contentiously, new industrial development.

City officials have promised what they describe as fair compensation for the lands and insist the plan is necessary to meet future housing targets and employment needs. The province has so far signalled its support for the proposal.

Still, many residents remain skeptical, questioning not only the fairness of the deal but also its necessity. Some voiced concerns that losing land to Barrie would diminish Springwater’s character and financial stability.

“I love Springwater Township. It’s a wonderful place to live, and I don’t want to see it get abused and shrink and become a poor, have-not township,” said resident John Spring, one of several who oppose the boundary change.

Others, however, took a different view, arguing the expansion would unlock stalled development opportunities and allow long-awaited projects to move forward.

Developer Paul Sadlon, who supports the boundary change, said his project depends on Barrie’s servicing capacity.

“Our development is ready to go,” he said. “We still have to go through Springwater and get all the approvals, but it all hinges on the servicing from the City of Barrie, and they’ve told us they can handle the developments.”

The issue has also drawn concern from Simcoe County council, which warned Barrie’s boundary expansion could cost local taxpayers millions in lost revenue and limit regional growth opportunities.

“The County is not supportive of the current terms of the forced annexation plan as currently outlined,” stated Warden Basil Clarke in a statement issued prior to the public meeting Wednesday.

County officials estimate employment lands along Highway 400 could generate up to 22,000 jobs and $85 million in annual tax revenue if kept within the county’s control. They argue those benefits could disappear if Barrie’s plan moves forward.

“We also remain concerned about environmentally sensitive or protected lands being part of an annexation into an urban boundary. These lands are more likely to remain protected under the County Official Plan,” Clarke added.

The City of Barrie released an update on Thursday, noting it aims to find a mutually beneficial solution that supports the region’s growth.

In the release, Barrie Mayor Alex Nuttall called the employment corridor a “game changer.”

“Barrie has been committed to working with our neighbours to find a solution that reflects the best interests of our communities,” he stated. “It will create thousands of jobs benefiting residents of the entire region including the County of Simcoe. Employment lands along Highway 400 will be a connection point to the Ring of Fire and will ensure the economic prosperity for the entire Region and Province of Ontario.”

Related Articles

• County pushes back on Barrie’s boundary expansion proposal
• Oro-Medonte mayor pushes back on Barrie’s boundary expansion plans, calls for focus on housing
• Barrie’s mayor addresses push for boundary expansion at Queen’s Park
• New report shifts focus to housing in Barrie’s boundary expansion debate