Warning: Graphic content. A Hamilton-based doctor who led a specialized dementia care ward sexually touched a nurse without her consent while at work, a disciplinary tribunal has found. The Ontario Physicians and Surgeons Discipline Tribunal deemed Dr. Atul Luthra’s conduct “disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional” in a decision dated Nov. 6, in which it found the allegations against the doctor had been proven “on a balance of probabilities.” In the decision, the tribunal cited testimony which stated that Luthra “touched the complainant in a sexual manner by putting his hand down her pants and under her shirt, made sexually suggestive comments to her and showed her pornography on his phone.” Luthra worked at St. Peter’s Hospital for decades, which is located at 88 Maplewood Ave. He worked as the medical director for the Behavioural Health Unit (BHU) since 2000 and was the interim Chief of Staff for 10 months, starting in November 2021. The decision noted that Luthra and a registered practical nurse who had been working in the unit since 2012 had a “good working relationship” until midway through 2021. That is when the nurse, the complainant, alleges that Luthra began make inappropriate comments, sexually touched her—even in front of a palliative patient—and showed her pornography at work, the decision notes. The nurse, whose identity is protected by a publication ban, brought the allegations forward in September 2022, after she said her manager pressed her for a reason why she was avoiding weekend shifts. According to the tribunal documents, she had not reported the allegations because she felt ashamed, embarrassed, terrified by the repercussions and didn’t think the hospital would believe her, given Luthra’s position at that time. Though the tribunal found flaws in the nurse’s testimony, they determined she was credible and reliable, saying the inconsistencies in her account did not suggest she was dishonest. “Neither presented a wholly smooth and consistent narrative. Ultimately, despite the flaws in the complainant’s testimony, we prefer it over that of the registrant when they conflict,” the decision reads. The tribunal questioned Luthra’s credibility, noting he sought to diminish how often the two interacted with each other, and provided an explanation to one of the allegations that “belied common sense.” ‘Ran that unit’ The alleged advances started with the offer of a back massage. In the decision, the nurse indicated Luthra had said on a couple of occasions that he gives “good back massages” as he was aware she played soccer and had suffered a back injury. This culminated in an alleged incident in the TV room, where she said Luthra asked to give her a massage. She said she “tried to make a joke of it,” and recounted Luthra saying something along the lines of: “Well, we can’t do it here.” When asked why she didn’t want to say no, the nurse said she didn’t want to upset him. “She felt that, as a doctor, compared to her position as an RPN, he had a lot of power over her and he basically ‘ran that unit,’” the decision reads. Luthra, for his part, denied talking about back massages and testified he never offered to give her one. A second alleged incident occurred in the fall of 2021 in a patient’s room. The nurse said she had entered the room when the complainant had entered the room with her medicine cart as she was going to see if her patient needed to be given medication. She said Luthra put his hand down her pants and touched her over her underwear in the patient’s room. “She remembers telling herself to just act normal but does not recall anything else about the rest of her shift,” the decision reads. Luthra denied the allegation, arguing this incident had “gross exaggerations.” The tribunal determined her core allegation was “clear and unshaken,” despite some flaws in her testimony. The nurse also alleged that Luthra had showed her pornography on his phone while they were alone at the nursing station, as he was complaining about how his Twitter feed was flooded with it and asked her for help to block it. The tribunal found it was not plausible Luthra would turn to her for help with this when he had other sources of help, like the research assistant who suggested using the social media platform to him. In response to that specific allegation,Luthra said he was “so ashamed” of himself and “begged the complainant’s forgiveness.” The decision notes Luthra took “full responsibility for being made aware of the fact that a person, who I considered a friend had been stressed by my behaviour … and, furthermore, had felt unsafe around me.” ‘Its out of control’ The most egregious allegation occurred on March 5, 2022, when the complainant said Luthra put his hand under her bra and touched her breast at the nursing station. She said she tried to get him to leave but he continued, and eventually she grabbed him by the shoulders and turned him away. The nurse testified that she felt powerless and though Luthra denied the allegations, the tribunal did not accept his denials. CTV News Toronto contacted Luthra and his lawyers for comment, but did not receive a response in time for publication. Though Hamilton Health Sciences (HHS) could not directly comment on the decision directly, citing legal and privacy obligations, the hospital network confirmed Luthra is no longer practising there. They would not comment on when Luthra stopped practising there and on what grounds he left his position. “HHS has established policies, processes and supports in place to help maintain a safe and respectful environment for all,” Wendy Stewart, communications advisor with HHS, wrote in an email. A penalty and costs hearing for Luthra will be scheduled, so any outcome—from suspension or revocation—will come at a later date.