Regina City Council axed an administration proposal for a study into downtown traffic flow. “It puts us in a position where our city admin will have to, probably, incrementally look at things as opposed to having a more comprehensive view of the city center,” Mayor Chad Bachynski told reporters following Wednesday’s council meeting. “Especially leading into more construction around [Saskatchewan] Drive, it’s a tough position to balance those things. For me, I was in favor of putting it towards the budget conversation, so I could see where everything else landed in the capital budget, but that’s okay.” Administration first brought the idea of the big picture look at downtown traffic flows to the executive committee last month. At the time city councillors voted against the idea – but it arose again at Wednesday’s council meeting upon the recommendation of Ward 9 Coun. Jason Mancinelli. “People have a lot of recommendations on how to fix our downtown,” he told his fellow council members. “Administration got some innovative, interesting ideas to do with transit and parking, but they have no vehicle to put those ideas to us for us to implement them.” “Compound that with the investment in 11th Avenue, and the rebuild of Saskatchewan Drive, and we are investing heavily in our downtown. Administration wants to come with a smart plan to make the downtown accessible and easy to maneuver for our residents so they can easily embrace their downtown again,” he added. Administration’s hope was to provide council with a recommended delivery plan for actions arising from the study to advance transportation, parking and mobility improvements within the downtown area. However, it came with a cost of $400,000 just to gather the information. “The study costs money,” Mancinelli noted. “The reason we’re debating this report is because there’s no money wanted to be spent on the study.” “I’m the last person that wants to just do another study,” added city manager of planning and community development Deborah Bryden. “I’m very much supportive of bringing action items forward. And so, as we indicated throughout our work, this is a large chunk of work we feel is important for our city center.” Ultimately, the idea of the study saw its end with a tie vote – five councillors in favour, five against – denying its approval. Couns. Mancinelli, Victoria Flores, Sobna Radons, Shanon Zachidniak and Mayor Bachynski voted in favour. Voting against were Couns. Dan Rashovich, George Tsiklis, David Froh, Mark Burton and Clark Bezo. Ward 5 Coun. Sarah Turnbull was not at Wednesday’s meeting. “Generally speaking, I would support this,” said Froh, the Councillor for Ward 3, which includes much of the downtown. “This is not the time to do that. I’ve got a laundry list of things residents and downtown businesses are asking us to invest in as it relates to our capital plan. Unfortunately, this study isn’t one of them.” Despite being struck down, administration will continue to evaluate improvements to downtown traffic where necessary. “We heard it could be, ‘is it a two way street? Is it a one way street? What does that parking look like?’ It’s a supplement to make sure everything works together,” explained Mayor Bachynski. Bachynski looked at 12th Avenue and Cornwall Street as an example to the oddities of Regina downtown traffic. “We’ll see how we how far we can get without having all the data on how everything compliments each other,” he said. “Because I think of some of the frustrations of doing an awkward U-turn and coming back down [Cornwall] again – how does that play into the bigger picture of downtown?” ‘Hollowing of downtown’ Despite voting against an idea to study fully city centre traffic, councillors did reaffirm their desire to continue examining the possibility of a property tax subclass for parking lots in the core. This idea first came forward in 2024, when then Coun. Andrew Stevens penned a motion to potentially create new property tax subclasses for what he called, ‘under utilized properties,’ including surface parking lots. Stevens hoped to spur development downtown by eliminating parking lots which often sit empty outside of working hours. City administration, however, is not sure it will work in practice. “Perhaps a subclass isn’t the appropriate tool to facilitate development,” said director of sustainable infrastructure Luke Grazier. “Perhaps it’s a specialized tax [which is] something new you see in other jurisdictions specific to parking lots.” Steven’s original motion never made it onto the council floor prior to his term as Ward 3 Coun. coming to an end in 2024. Mancinelli was also a member of that iteration of council. “I’m a counselor for northwest Regina and this has to do with the downtown,” he said. “The reason I’m advocating for this so loudly is because the hollowing out of our downtown that’s happened over the last two decades has cost the residents I represent immensely.” Around 10 per cent of Regina’s downtown is surface parking lot space. “[New] standalone surface parking lots are currently generally prohibited,” explained Grazier. “And by nature of that, it means existing ones are not allowed to make substantial improvements to those lots.” Administration advocated to the provincial government through its last review of the Cities Act, which governs municipal responsibilities – including available tax tools. Regina hoped the province would open avenues for new tax revenue solutions with this review, but ultimately property tax subclasses for “underutilized properties” was not one of them. “Unfortunately, we’re pretty limited,” Grazier said to council. “I’m not aware of anything we could do to compel [parking lot owners] to make upgrades. Certainly you could look at incentives or that type of thing. But it would still be voluntary.” Administration also says a traffic study may have found if there are too many – or not enough – surface parking lots in Regina. “You have to look at it as one big picture,” said Mayor Bachynski. “That’s part of what that study would have helped a little bit with, for sure. But really it’s a combination of things. We have vacancies downtown – that plays a role – into whether we need, or whether surface parking lots are required in lieu of more buildings.” Council voted 8-2 in favour of having administration continue advocating to the province to open the door for the possibility of a new property tax subclass. Coun. Bezo and Mancinelli voted against the idea. “We talk a lot about parking all the time,” Bachynski said. “Whether it’s street parking or surface lots, these are all tangible factors people rely on to navigate downtown.” Bachynski does not believe the subclass conversation with the province will be fruitful until the Cities Act’s next review in four years time – if at all.