Eastern Ontario community will not grant Alto access to land for high-speed rail study

A group of mayors in eastern Ontario is refusing to grant Alto access to municipal land to study the proposed high-speed rail line. CTV’s Dylan Dyson reports.

The proposed high-speed rail line between Ottawa and Montreal is facing a roadblock east of Ottawa, as an eastern Ontario community refused to grant the Crown corporation access to municipal land to study the Alto line.

Alto is tasked with building high-speed rail connecting Toronto, Ottawa, Montreal and Quebec City, with the first phase to be built between Ottawa and Montreal. Alto has begun conducting environmental assessments on private properties for the proposed rail line, requesting permission from property owners to collect environmental data for the proposed route.

However, the United Counties of Prescott-Russell council passed a resolution last week to refuse to grant Alto access to county land for the studies and declining to sign a non-disclosure agreement with Alto.

“Major infrastructure projects must be transparent, accountable and respectful of local communities from day one,” said Mario Zanth, mayor of Clarence-Rockland and the warden for the United Counties of Prescott-Russell.

“Our residents deserve to know exactly what is being proposed; how it’s going to affect farmland, property owners, local roads, the environment and taxpayers before decisions are made behind closed doors — mainly expropriations.”

• ‘We would destroy the neighbourhood’: Alto CEO rules out downtown Ottawa stop

The vote by the United Counties of Prescott-Russell council comes after the Township of Champlain, the Nation Municipality, the Municipality of Casselman and the Township of Alfred and Plantagenet all passed resolutions to oppose the Alto plan.

In a video on Facebook, Zanth said a non-disclosure agreement would have “limited open discussion with the public.”

Alto has faced opposition from rural property owners and politicians at all three levels of government. In April, 12 mayors and reeves across eastern Ontario signed a letter to oppose the Alto project.

Zanth says while economic development and transportation are important, “protecting our communities and rural character and the right of residents to be informed matters as well.”

“This was not a vote against progress, it was a vote for transparency, it was a vote for local autonomy and responsible decision-making,” Zanth said in a video on Facebook.

“The message yesterday was simple; if you want to work with our communities, you must do so openly and respectfully. Nation building should not be community dividing.”

In February, the United Counties of Prescott and Russell voted to create a steering committee to develop the region’s position and strategy for the Alto high-speed rail line.

Alto wrapped up public consultations this spring on the first phase of the project between Ottawa and Montreal. A report is expected to be released this summer on the findings and the next steps.

Alto meets with officials

In a statement to CTV News Ottawa, Alto said it met with the warden of Prescott County and are in the process of scheduling a follow-up meeting.

“We hope to build into a series of regular touch points,” Alto said.

“We will continue to work closely with municipalities across the corridor. These agreements, which are widely used in the industry, help structure discussions and two-way data sharing around preliminary working assumptions, which are expected to evolve over time, in order to assess their technical feasibility.”

Alto said a report on its 100 days of public consultations will be released later in June, and another round of public consultations will be held in the fall.

Ottawa signed NDA with Alto

Ottawa city council was told in December that the city has signed a non-disclosure agreement with Alto.

“I have signed an NDA on behalf of the City of Ottawa to gain access to the detailed mapping and route planning options under consideration, to ensure our most up to date information is informing the decisions of Alto,” said Marcia Wallace, general manager of planning, development and building services.

“City of Ottawa staff from multiple departments are working closely on this file. Integrating the high-speed rail system with our land use and transportation networks is a high priority for both parties.”

With files from CTV News Ottawa’s Dylan Dyson

• Sign up now for daily CTV News Ottawa newsletters
• The information you need to know, sent directly to you: Download the CTV News App