A Quebec tribunal has ordered a caregiver to repay $120,000 he took from an elderly man at a private seniors’ residence. But police never laid charges, and now there are calls to reopen the case. The former Residence Excelsiors in Knowlton, about 100 kilometres outside of Montreal, has been closed for more than three years. It was once home to Byron Wilson, 89. In 2022, Wilson’s niece, Nancy Wilson, visited him and noticed something was wrong. “I saw that he had written these large amounts of money with his cheque,” she said. “I asked him who this person was that he was writing these cheques to.” The person cashing them was Lourenco Mbuta, her uncle’s caregiver. “It was a shock. At the time, I couldn’t understand what was happening and why it was happening. I just knew it was wrong,” said Nancy Wilson. According to Quebec’s Human Rights Tribunal, Mbuta cashed 18 cheques totaling $110,000 between January and June 2022. Before that, in November 2021, $8,214.89 worth of Apple products were purchased using Wilson’s account. “[My uncle] was not the type of person to just give away money,” said Nancy Wilson, who lives in Newfoundland and Labrador. She says her uncle was alone after his wife died and suffered from memory loss. “He was just in shock when he realized what was going on and what happened,” she said. “It was really hard on him.” After learning what had happened in June, Byron Wilson died the following August. Under Quebec law, a person working in a health-care setting cannot receive significant gifts from patients. According to the tribunal’s decision, Mbuta says he did not know that was a rule and claims it was not addressed in his training. He says he had a close relationship with Wilson and even called him “grandpa.” But Nancy Wilson is not convinced. “I don’t buy it at all, because I was talking to my uncle; he never mentioned anything about this person,” she said. Seniors at risk Research from the federal Justice Department shows 10 per cent of seniors experience some form of abuse each year, with financial exploitation among the most common. “Be aware of those people being alone; they are the most subject to abuse,” said Paul Brunet, a patient rights advocate. No charges laid A report was filed with the Sûreté du Québec (SQ), but criminal charges were never laid. Police told CTV News they do not comment on current or past cases. Criminal defence attorney Eric Sutton said that without witnesses or the alleged victim, building a case is challenging. “That might turn the police away from pressing charges because they know that they can’t reasonably obtain a conviction if they proceed,” he said. Nancy Wilson and Brunet want the SQ to reopen the case. Back at work Following the allegations, the agency Mbuta worked for, Arma Santé, let him go. But in 2024, Mbuta was working at another seniors’ residence, CHSLD Vigi Reine Elizabeth in Montreal’s Notre-Dame-de-Grâce borough. The residence told CTV News he was let go last week after it discovered what had happened. It says it did a criminal background check on him, but nothing came up. Nancy Wilson says there is a gap in the system. “They look to see if there’s a criminal record, but they’re not required to look anywhere else to find out about this type of behaviour and whether or not somebody is guilty of it,” she said. The tribunal ordered Mbuta to repay $118, 214.89 to the estate of Byron Wilson, plus $5,000 in damages. CTV News reached out to Mbuta, his lawyer, and Arma Santé, but did not hear back in time for broadcast.