The five former members of Canada’s world junior hockey team who were on trial for sexual assault were acquitted in the high-profile London, Ont., trial Thursday, but the jury is still out on whether or not they’ll be able to resume their NHL careers. Michael McLeod, Carter Hart, Dillon Dubé and Cal Foote were active NHL players at the time of their 2024 arrests, which came days after all four players were granted leave from their clubs. Formenton, an Ottawa Senators draft pick, has not played in the NHL since 2022. Before Thursday’s proceedings, protestors gathered outside a London Ont., courtroom Thursday morning before the judge ruled and again in the evening, after the decisions came down. Statement from the NHL The NHL stated the allegations in the case were “very disturbing,” even if not deemed criminal. The league also called the behaviour of the players “unacceptable.” “We will be reviewing and considering the judge’s findings,” the statement read. “While we conduct that analysis and determine next steps, the players charged in this case are ineligible to play in the league.” Statement from NHLPA The NHLPA said ruling the players ineligible while the NHL further evaluates the case does not align with the terms of their collective bargaining agreement and that its players should “have the opportunity to return to work.” “Dillon Dube, Cal Foote, Alex Formenton, Carter Hart, and Michael McLeod were acquitted of all charges by Justice Carroccia of the Ontario Superior Court,” the NHLPA’s statement read. “After missing more than a full season of their respective NHL careers, they should now have the opportunity to return to work. The NHL’s declaration that the Players are ‘ineligible’ to play pending its further analysis of the Court’s findings is inconsistent with the discipline procedures set forth in the CBA. “We are addressing this dispute with the League and will have no further comment at this time.” Hockey Canada statement In November 2023, Hockey Canada issued a public update on the independent adjudicative panel that held a hearing to determine whether certain members of the 2018 National Junior Team breached Hockey Canada’s code of conduct, and if so, what sanctions should be imposed against those players. Shortly after the panel issued its final report to all involved parties, a notice of appeal was filed and an independent appeal board was created, which was permitted under Hockey Canada’s Investigation and Adjudication Procedures. In September 2024, Hockey Canada was informed by the appeal board that it had granted a motion to adjourn the hearing until the criminal trial in London involving five former National Junior Team players, each of whom remains suspended from Hockey Canada-sanctioned programming, has ended. Since then, we have not been provided with an update on potential timing for the hearing from the appeal board, which was not unexpected as the criminal proceedings were ongoing. In its reasons for decision, the appeal board noted that Hockey Canada has sought to proceed expeditiously throughout the appeal process and that any further delay has resulted from its decision to adjourn the hearing until after the trial, and not from anything we have failed to do as an organization. To ensure that we do not interfere with the integrity of the ongoing appeal of the independent adjudicative panel’s report, we are not able to comment further at this time." Statement from Carter Hart’s lawyer, Megan Savard Mr. Hart is innocent of sexual assault. He is grateful to Justice Carroccia for her thoughtful, humane, and compassionate reasons. A criminal trial is rarely an opportunity for vindication. Here, it is. It is both gratifying and unsurprising to hear an impartial and fully informed decision-maker accept Mr. Hart’s testimony about what happened on June 19, 2018, as unshaken, credible and true. he public narrative of this event was, until this trial, one-sided and untested. now the criminal process has shown it to be false. To anyone who is surprised or angered by today’s outcome, it is the direct result of the media’s ongoing failure to publicize the weaknesses in the prosecution’s case as it unfolded. The Office of the crown attorney knew what today’s verdict was likely to be. And the evidence at trial came as no surprise to them or anyone with full knowledge of the investigation. Almost every single feature of the evidence that Justice Carroccia identified today as fatal flaws for the Crown was known to prosecutors and to police from 2018. Today’s outcome was not just predictable, it was predicted. The Crown Attorney did not have to take this case to trial. Mr. Hart in particular was willing to engage in a restorative justice process. He was willing to be publicly named and prepared to use his public platform to teach other athletes about how to ensure that their sexual encounters are responsible and thoughtful. Instead of pursuing restorative justice, the Crown forced a distressing and unnecessary trial to the detriment of Mr. Hart, his co-defendants, the complainant and the Canadian public. Mr. Hart regrets that it took a criminal trial for the truth to come out, but he has learned from the experience and he is committed to sharing what he has learned with others in his personal circle and in his professional life. He will be taking time today to process today’s outcome and is grateful to his family, his friends, and his supporters for standing by him during this profoundly challenging time. Thank you. Statement from Michael McLeod’s lawyer, David Humphrey Good afternoon. So my name is David Humphrey. I, together with Anna Zhang, my associate, we’ve represented Mike McCloud in this trial. Mr. McCloud has asked me to deliver this brief statement on his behalf. Mr. McLeod will not be speaking to the media, and I understand the other players will not be speaking to the media. I will not be taking questions, and other counsel who come to address you, they will not be taking any questions. Mr. McLeod had confidence in the justice process. And he welcomes Justice Carroccia’s decision confirming that he and his co-defendants are not guilty of sexual assault. ustice Carroccia’s carefully reasoned decision represents a resounding vindication for Mr. McLeod and for his co-defendants. Justice Carroccia found that the complainant’s testimony was incredible and was unreliable. For years, public perception was shaped by a one-sided narrative from a civil lawsuit that went unchallenged, in large part because Hockey Canada settled the claim without first informing or consulting the players. The decision was made unilaterally and the players were only told of the lawsuit and the settlement after the fact. they’d been consulted, they would have refused to settle and they would have vigorously contested EM’s allegations. That version of events dominated headlines and created a lasting and a false impression of guilt. It was only through this criminal trial that the allegations were fully and finally tested. The court compared the complainant’s 2018 statements to the police, which rightly resulted in no charges, with the later conflicting civil claim. The key elements of EM’s story were contradicted by the evidence, exposing serious falsehood and leading to today’s clear and just verdict of not guilty. Justice Carroccia rejected EM’s claims of fear and her claims of non-consent. That should be the takeaway from today’s judgment. The damage to Mr. McLeod’s reputation and his career has been significant. But today’s decision begins to restore what was very unfairly taken away from him. Mr. McLeod is deeply grateful to his family, friends, his agent, and everybody who stood by him. Thank you. Statement from Dillon Dube’s lawyer, Julie Santa Rosa For Mr. Dubé, this has been a long and difficult process. He is relieved by the outcome and he is grateful that Justice Carroccia decided what she did and did so fairly and efficiently. Throughout this trial, Mr. Dubé was impressed by the fairness and impartiality demonstrated by her Honour. This decision comes as a result of careful deliberation by Her Honour. She engaged with the evidence in a thoughtful, methodical, and principled manner. Her reasons reflect not only a command of the legal principles at stake, but also a deep sense of responsibility in assessing the evidence, applying the law, and demonstrating a strong commitment to justice. Mr. Dubé has always maintained his innocence. He is thankful for all of the unwavering support from his friends and family who have also believed in him. For all of you that have been by his side throughout this period of time, you know who you are. We thank you. Mr. Dubé is hopeful that everyone can move forward from this in a positive manner. He is requesting privacy during this period of time. In view of the court’s decision, Mr. Dube will not be making any further statements at this time. Thank you. Statement from Alex Formenton’s lawyer, Dan Brown Alex Formenton was barely 18 years old and on the verge of a promising hockey career that came to a screeching on June 18th, 2018 after what was meant to be a night of celebration. For the last seven years, he’s lived under a dark cloud. The public now knows what Alex has always maintained, that he is completely innocent of this false allegation. But this case has erupted into a massively publicized social cause. Alex’s face has appeared on millions of screens and pages, and there can be little doubt that an untold number of people out there believed he was guilty simply because he was accused of a crime long before any evidence was presented in court. This rush to judgment, to believe the worst of people, is one of the most regrettable of human traits. So too is our reluctance to change that opinion even when it’s proven wrong after a full and fair trial. Notwithstanding Justice Carroccia’s unequivocal exoneration of Alex today, there will inevitably be those who will believe he committed the crime. Nobody in room 209 that night has emerged unscarred from this event. The criminal court process is a bruising experience for everyone, but never more than when a case is high profile and incorporates such high stakes. In Alex’s case, he was condemned and felt banished from society. This experience for him has been crushing. Nonetheless, the impact of this case has changed Alex as a person and he’s matured well beyond his years. It’s inevitable that some people will not forgive Alex for what he was accused of doing. Others, however, will understand that this tragic matter rightly comes to an end today. Alex has never minimized his role in this sexual encounter or denied in engaging in consensual sexual activity with the complainant. He fully cooperated with the police investigation and provided investigators with a complete account of his behaviour back in 2018. Alex’s narrative isn’t conjecture. His police statement was corroborated at trial by several Crown witnesses, by video evidence and was even supported in large measure by the complainant’s evidence herself. Even Justice Carroccia said today that she accepted that Alex told the truth in that police statement. And while no police investigation is perfect, the London police got it right seven years ago, when they decided it would be a mistake to charge Alex. The evidence always demonstrated that he didn’t commit a sexual assault. However political and media pressure brought this allegation back into the spotlight in 2022, and the Crown attorney knowingly forged ahead with a hopeless prosecution. Besides the human toll to everyone involved, this lengthy legal process exhausted valuable resources that could’ve been deployed elsewhere in the justice system but were lost here. Alex, his family and his defence team are grateful to Justice Carroccia for her careful consideration of all the evidence that was presented at this trial. She has reached a just and correct verdict that must be respected. Nobody disputes that sexual assault is a terrible societal plague, and Alex sincerely hopes that this prosecution doesn’t stop the quest to combat sexual violence and to bring genuine offenders to justice. However, an accusation is just that, an accusation. This case stands for the fact that we must never lose sight of the fundamental right to be presumed innocent. Now more than ever before, a fair response to sexual assault claims requires a balanced perspective and public trust in the decision-making of the courts. Anything less only harms the justice system and the cause of eliminating sexual violence. Thank you. Statement from Cal Foote’s lawyer, Julianna Greenspan At the start of this trial, Cal Foote walked into this courthouse, an innocent man, and he walks out today exactly that. Cal never lost faith that justice would be done despite the clamour of external pressure. pressures and agendas outside the courthouse doors. Criminal investigations and the trial process must always be free from these influences. On behalf of Cal and his family, we appreciate the court’s careful and thorough consideration and for the just verdict delivered today. Seven years ago, Cal was 19. He is now 26. That is a significant part of a young man’s life. He is still young. He has a wonderful future ahead of him, and he is eager to embark on his next chapter. Thank you.