Richard Masson, former CEO of the Alberta Petroleum Marketing Commission, speaks with Alberta Primetime’s Michael Higgins about the province’s new oilsands growth program, which the government says will provide greater royalty certainty during project development and help fill a future Pacific Link pipeline. Participants will pay two per cent in royalties annually for the first five years, and 10 per cent by year 10. This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Michael Higgins: What makes this framework necessary? Richard Masson: This, to my mind, is part of the grand bargain. If you go back a few months, we heard the prime minister saying the Pacific Link pipeline can happen only if the Pathways carbon capture project happens, and you heard the industry saying we don’t think there’s enough fiscal support from governments for that to go forward. Then the federal government said let us do this productivity mega deduction, which allows for quicker capital write-offs for all kinds of investment, but includes these pathways projects. Alberta is now changing the royalty structure to incent new production. So all those things together make up the package that I think the industry has been waiting for, that allows them to go to their board of directors and say we want to accelerate growth in the oilsands, and we think the environment is set up for that. MH: On the royalties front, is this to say current rates are too high to entice this needed production, even with the commitment of the public dollars for Pacific Link and those deductions that you’re referring to? RM: To my mind, this is mostly a strong signal by the Alberta government that they are putting in some support for new projects. When I look back at the average royalty rate over the last 17 years, it’s been 5.03 per cent. Or if I look over the last 10 years, it’s been five and a quarter percent. That’s for the gross royalty that happens in the initial years of a project before it hits what’s called payout. This new framework is a time-sensitive thing rather than a price-sensitive thing. So it starts at two per cent for five years, then creeps up to six per cent for the last couple of years of a 10-year period. When you average that out, it’s about three-and-a-half percent. So in that sense, you’re giving up one-and-a-half or one-and-three-quarters per cent, if the past is a good predictor of the future, and that’s never exactly known. But it’s not a big giveaway. What it does, though, is it says to the industry: Yes, we are putting some money on the table, we’re providing a level of certainty upfront, which is one of the things the industry was looking for, and the main royalty system stays intact. After that 10-year period, we go into the net revenue royalty, which is the main part of how we earn money from the oilsands – a 25 to 40 per cent net cash flow royalty – and so I’m pleased that that part of the system hasn’t been changed. MH: To what degree is Alberta competing for the investment that is necessary to double this production? Is this a-do-or-die dilemma? RM: I wouldn’t say it’s like it has been sometimes in the past. The world is looking for our oil, and we know how to produce it. And so the question really is for companies: Can they convince their boards of directors and their shareholders that it’s worth taking on new greenfield projects? Typically, the oilsands grows at 80,000 or 100,000 barrels a year each year. In order to fill up the million barrels a day of new pipeline capacity that is the incremental expansions of Trans Mountain, the new South Bow, and the Enbridge ones, that takes a while at that rate. And if you want to build a million-barrel-a-day pipeline on top of that to the west coast, you’ve got to have more production coming. And so these companies now have to go to their boards and say, “I want to start a new project.” Imperial, for example, has the Aspen project, which could be 150,000 barrels a day. They need to convince them that you know spending billions of dollars on that is a wise bet, and so this now incents them a little bit, and it shows that the Alberta government is very serious, and so we would expect to see over the coming year several announcements of big projects that haven’t moved forward started to move forward. MH: Between the new royalty framework, the federal mega deduction and the other government commitments, there should be little reason for oilsands companies not to step up to the plate now and make those investment commitments. RM: Well, there’s still many risks, of course. This, you know, this helps, but it isn’t the final answer. We still don’t know what the Pacific Link Pipeline will cost. We don’t know the eight First Nations who have taken it to court, whether they’re going to win or how long these court cases will take, or if others will step in. We don’t know what the toll is going to be on that pipeline and whether it’ll be competitive. And the thing that has been bugging me for a long time: we don’t know if there’s enough diluent to go with a bitumen to actually allow it to flow down the pipeline. So there are many challenges that remain. Another one is labour. Will there be enough labour to build all these projects? I did a quick calculation myself about the upstream oilsands investment, the pipelines, the carbon capture project, the LNG projects. I came up with $235 billion of investment that’s required over the coming decade to make this all happen, can we get enough workers? Can we have enough companies prepared to step up to the plate to do this, or will we end up in one of these hyperinflation situations again? Right now it looks like everybody, at least, is moving in the right direction, the same direction, which is a good thing. MH: You brought up the Pathways project earlier. Where do you see all of this leaving that carbon capture project, which had a Nov. 15 deadline to sign definitive agreements, did it not? RM: Yeah. My understanding is that they’re continuing to work on actual documents that are agreements between the governments and and the Pathways companies that would allow for them to understand the system that’s going to apply to them for the next bunch of years, to go to their boards and be able to start building pathways. They’re looking at sequestering six megatons as the initial volume and then growing from there. It’s a big ask for the industry, but something I think that’s quite necessary. I view the oilsands as one of these global resources that’s going to be used for 30, 40 years. As long as we’re using oil, oilsands has a role in that mix, and we need to make sure that we develop it in an environmentally responsible way, including reducing the CO2 footprint. Pathways is part of that. Some of these new investments are going to apply solvent-assisted SAGD (steam assisted gravity drainage), which injects butane and things like that with the steam, so it vastly lowers the steam and reduces the greenhouse gases. These are all innovations that we need to take on to be global leaders in this space. And because there’s a new investment cycle coming, now is the time to apply some of the technologies that have been in development for quite a while. We’re going to need all of those answers because there’s so much being asked of this industry by governments to grow quickly.