A Saskatoon judge declared a mistrial in Kenneth Braun’s sexual assault trial Tuesday morning and dismissed the jury. Justice Daryl Labach found the Crown’s cross-examination of Braun was inappropriate, and that instructions to the jury would not be enough to address the problem. “The fairness of the trial has been compromised,” Labach ruled. Braun, 70, is charged with three counts of sexual assault and one count of sexual exploitation of a young person while in a position of trust or authority. The allegations span from 1996 to 2022 while Braun practiced massage therapy out of his home. Some members of the gallery wept as Labach announced the mistrial. “Disgusting,” one person said. Defence successfully argues Braun’s credibility irrevocably damaged The defence applied for a mistrial after senior Crown prosecutor Lana Morelli cross-examined Braun on Friday evening. The questioning may have exposed jurors to inadmissible evidence. Braun’s lawyer, Brian Pfefferle, argued his client would have to refer to that evidence to answer truthfully. Morelli argued her cross-examination had created no possibility of prejudice to Braun. She suggested Labach give the jury instructions to disregard certain comments made during her questioning. “There’s nothing you can do to un-ring the impression he gave — which was an impression of being evasive and not direct,” Pfefferle said. Before Labach made his decision, Pfefferle proposed dismissing the jury and continuing the trial before the judge alone. The Crown declined. “The Crown determined that it was not appropriate. It had started with the jury, and it should end with the jury,” Morelli told journalists. Morelli said she stood by that decision even after the mistrial was declared. What happens now? If the case goes back to trial, it will start over. The matter is expected to return to court for a pre-trial conference in the coming weeks. The Crown and defence will discuss how to proceed. No new trial date has been set. “We believe it took an extraordinary amount of courage for all of these complainants to come forward, to testify and to give their stories of what happened,” Morelli said. Pfefferle said the defence is concerned about whether a new trial can be scheduled within a reasonable time. Under the Supreme Court of Canada’s Jordan framework, criminal cases must be completed within a specific timeframe, or charges can be stayed. “Obviously, this is a case where we want to be finished,” Pfefferle said. “Everybody wants to be finished. However, we need to make sure the case is fair.”