The debate over the future of bike lanes on University Avenue will continue after Halifax Regional Council voted to send a proposed redesign to city committees for further feedback. Members of the Halifax Cycling Coalition made their presence known Tuesday, wearing their helmets in chambers, as councillors prepared to vote on a proposal that could see some lanes downgraded to a less expensive alternative. “The cost to construct the bikeway, including lighting, potential new traffic signal, 45% contingency and net HST is estimated at $3.5 million,” reads a staff report. Last August, Mayor Andy Fillmore’s motion to “direct the CAO to carry out additional planning, design reassessment, and targeted stakeholder engagement” regarding University Avenue, and to review “alternative network solutions and cost savings opportunities for the AAA bike network” passed. Halifax Cycling Coalition Chair David Trueman argues the $3.5 million figure pales in comparison to the municipality’s $140 million roads budget. “One of the basic precepts of the staff report is to abandon the standard of all ages and all abilities (AAA),” he told reporters. “That’s just a euphemism for unsafe.” The coalition also raised concerns about the possibility of moving away from a previously proposed design that had already undergone extensive public consultation. “To throw all that out and jump willy-nilly to alternatives that have had no public consultation, would be, a really, well, can I use the word ‘stupid’ move,” he said. “I’m delighted that council saw fit.” Council ultimately voted to refer the motion to two committees, allowing for additional feedback from those who use the bike lanes before a final decision is made. Municipal staff told councillors the decision would not delay the project, as construction is not scheduled to begin until 2028. Cost saving opportunities The proposed changes are part of a broader effort to reduce costs, with other potential adjustments that could trim approximately $10 million from the budget. “Eight potential alternatives for seven bikeway segments were identified that could reduce construction costs by approximately $9.7 to $11.4 million,” reads the staff report. “Although these alternatives are expected to reduce costs, there are trade-offs (e.g., cycling facilities that may not appeal to an all-ages-and-abilities target audience, on-street parking impacts),” it says. “Further development and evaluation of these alternatives is expected to impact both design and construction timelines.” However, not everyone around the council table supported delaying a decision. Losing a 15-2 vote, Fillmore and Coun. Trish Purdy were the only two members who wanted to proceed with the motion. “Those committees open the door to redesign, which open the door to increased costs, which open the door to delay,” Fillmore told reporters. “Not that I ever wanted to debate bike lanes again, but, here we are,” Purdy sighed. “I think we know where people stand. “We have a responsibility to our taxpayers to be spending in the most responsible way possible.” Most expensive option isn’t necessary: cycling advocate For the Halifax Cycling Coalition, the concern remains that choosing a less expensive design now could create challenges down the road, particularly if the finished bike lanes are considered inadequate and there is resistance to making further improvements. “It has to be built to an adequate standard,” Trueman said. “Now, that doesn’t mean it has to be gold plated.” The coalition says it supports on-road bike lanes separated from traffic by a concrete curb, an option that would cost significantly less than raised bike lanes. According to prior city staff estimates, on-road bike lanes with concrete curbs would cost approximately $1,100 per metre, compared to $4,500 per metre for raised, protected bike lanes. Despite their differing views on how council should proceed, Fillmore and Trueman agree on one point: simply painting lines on the road is not a safe solution. Both acknowledge that improving safety is essential to encouraging more people to cycle. The debate will go to the city’s Active Transportation Advisory Committee and Transportation Standing Committee before returning to council at a later date. For more Nova Scotia news, visit our dedicated provincial page