A Manitoba judge has set a judicial recount in a reeve’s race after a scrutineer alleged the runner-up actually won. The recount is set for Monday at 10 a.m. at the Rural Municipality of La Broquerie’s municipal office, according to a Nov. 16 letter from Court of King’s Bench Justice Gérald Chartier. Chartier wrote that the date and location were set with the agreement of all parties. Official results show Ivan Normandeau defeating challenger Lewis Weiss 857 votes to 848. But Nettie Weiss, a scrutineer for Lewis Weiss’s campaign, says in an affidavit that her own tally gave Lewis 12 more votes than Normandeau. Henri Turenne, the RM’s senior election official, disputed the allegation that the official results are wrong. He told CTV News he believes the scrutineer made a mistake in her count. “I have complete confidence in my voting officials,” he said. The recount follows an application Lewis filed in the Court of King’s Bench on Nov. 4, supported by affidavits from himself and Nettie. Nettie’s total of 1,756 votes cast is 51 more than the 1,705 valid votes on the publicly posted statement of the vote. Nettie says she noted the final results from the tally sheet at each polling station and added them up before the results were announced. She says her figures matched at the Ward 1 stations but differed at three of the five in Ward 2. She filed copies of her sheets as exhibits. According to her affidavit, she told Lewis he had won, then learned later that night that the publicized results showed a different outcome. She then approached Turenne and asked for a recount of the ballots, the affidavit says. In his own affidavit, which relies on his scrutineer’s account, Lewis says he believes the statement of the vote and the statement of official results do not accurately record the valid votes for either candidate. He says he believes an accurate count “would reverse the outcome of the election.” Lewis was first elected reeve in 2014 and held onto it until 2022 when he lost to Normandeau. Normandeau said he served eight years as a councillor while Lewis was reeve. “We have a good rapport,” Normandeau told CTV News on Thursday. CTV News has contacted Lewis’s lawyer, Mathieu Lafrenière, for comment and has not heard back. The RM of La Broquerie recount follows another set earlier this month in the RM of Yellowhead, where the mayor’s race was decided by one vote. A judge set that recount for Dec. 3 at the Brandon courthouse. Nick Krawetz, deputy executive director of the Association of Manitoba Municipalities, said six of the 135 municipal elections held in October had head of council races decided by fewer than 10 votes. Besides Yellowhead and La Broquerie, those were Melita, Minitonas-Bowsman and Minto-Odanah (each decided by five votes) and Mountain (seven votes). In a statement earlier this week, a provincial spokesperson said the Municipal Councils and School Boards Elections Act presumes election officials’ counts are accurate. The statement said the act includes safeguards such as requiring at least two election officials to conduct the count and allowing candidates and their scrutineers to observe it. It said that if no candidate or voter has concerns, there is “no obvious reason to consume judicial resources with an automatic recount.”