The family of a Chatham woman who was killed in 2022 remains hopeful for justice after a murder charge was dismissed last week. David William Thomas had been charged with first-degree murder, arson with disregard for human life, and indignity to a body in the death of his 22-year-old daughter, Bayli Sellars. Sellars’ body was found in a fire at their Chatham home in June 2022. However, before a trial could begin, Ontario Superior Court Justice Brian Dubé ruled police violated Thomas’ Charter rights during the investigation. The ruling rendered some evidence inadmissible, and the murder charge was subsequently dismissed at the Crown’s request. In a statement provided to CTV News, members of Sellars’ family noted they remain hopeful the justice system can provide closure. “Although we are disappointed with this outcome, it is not the end of Bayli’s story. We hold out the hope and faith that the appeal will be granted and that the person responsible for her death will be held accountable and the family can have some kind of closure and put this nightmare to rest,” the statement reads. Charter ruling Across a more than 60-page decision, Dubé noted several of Thomas’ Charter rights had been violated across police investigations. The infringements include the arrest of Thomas in British Columbia in 2024, while questions were also raised about the reliability of officers involved on the night of Sellars’ death. Significant focus was put on the search of Thomas’ phone, which occurred on the night Sellars’ body was discovered. Court documents indicate Thomas allegedly stated, “what the f*** is this?” before he threw his phone onto the ground. The phone was picked up by an officer who believed they had implied consent to view it and read messages before they scrolled through the phone. “In my view, the evidence falls short of establishing, on a balance of probabilities, that the accused, by his words or conduct, knowingly authorized the police to handle, examine, or access the phone pursuant to valid consent, thereby relinquishing or waiving his reasonable expectation of privacy in the device and its contents,” Dubé wrote. In an interview on AM800 News, defence lawyer Michael Moon provided more background on the decision. “There were several pieces of evidence that the court found had been obtained by the police in violation of Mr. Thomas’s constitutional rights, his Charter rights,” Moon said. “What they saw on the phone, for reasons which were beyond me, was that they saw a picture of what appeared to be his daughter, bound in a chair and a kidnapping or a message,” Moon said. Crown appeal In a statement to CTV News, Scott Kerwin, the Assistant Crown Attorney, confirmed an appeal has been filed on the Charter ruling. “Following the pretrial motion Charter ruling of Justice Dube on September 25, 2026, the Crown invited an acquittal on the murder charge after arraignment – after the excluded evidence, there was no longer a reasonable prospect of conviction with the evidence that remained,” Kerwin said. Kerwin noted the Crown entered prosecutorial stays on the charges of arson and indignity to a body as there remains a “reasonable prospect” of conviction. After the decision, the Chatham-Kent Police Service released a statement defending the actions of its members. “The appeal will determine whether the evidence in question should be admissible at trial. It is important to recognize that the appeal process exists specifically to review legal rulings and ensure that significant questions of law are properly considered through the judicial system,” the statement read in part. “We are confident that our officers acted in accordance with their lawful duties and responsibilities.”