A routine task became an early test of London’s newly-elected council, as the selection of councillors to sit as the chairs of three municipal standing committees sparked debate about how to best collaborate on decisions governed by strong mayor powers. On Wednesday, the Strategic Priorities and Policy Committee (SPPC) heard a motion from Coun. Elizabeth Peloza proposing a different approach to choosing the chairs and vice-chairs the Infrastructure and Corporate Services Committee (ICSC), the Planning and Environment Committee (PEC), and the Community and Protective Services (CAPS) Committee. Peloza’s letter suggested that it would be more collaborative to have each standing committee nominate their own choices for the leadership roles, and forward them to Mayor Josh Morgan for appointment. “This letter came from a conversation I had proactively and respectfully with the mayor,” Peloza explained to colleagues on SPPC. However, Deputy Mayor Shawn Lewis challenged whether the proposal could proceed because strong mayor powers provided by the provincial government include a requirement that the mayor appoint standing committee chairs, “It’s my opinion that this motion is actually out of order.” After consulting with the city clerk, Deputy Mayor Corrine Rahman agreed that Peloza’s motion was out of order. Instead, Mayor Josh Morgan sought council’s non-binding support for his selections: Lewis to chair the ICSC, Coun. Skylar Franke to chair PEC, and Coun. Hadleigh McAlister to chair CAPS. “There’s committee (meetings) starting on the 30th of November. This is a super tight timeframe at the start of the term,” the mayor reminded colleagues. “I’m totally open to lots of ways that we can improve the process for next year and the year after. But at the start here, I feel some level of obligation to get things set-up and going.” The subsequent discussion exposed different views about whether every councillor is equally qualified to chair a standing committee. “I feel very strongly, very strongly, that we should be rotating the positions of chairs and vice-chairs as much as possible, and that every member of council during a council term should have the opportunity, if they’re willing,” asserted Coun. Sam Trosow. Lewis argued councillors require certain abilities to chair standing committees. “Look around the (council) horseshoe. We don’t all come with equal skills and abilities. In different areas we have different skills and abilities. One of the key things for me in the selection of a chair is the people with the skills and abilities to chair a committee,” explained Lewis. Budget Chair Steven Lehman supported Morgan’s choices, emphasizing the demands of running a meeting. “It’s a challenging job to be a chair,” Lehman explained. “You’re listening to debate, but you’re also having to act as a referee in some regards, not only with committee people, but often with people in the gallery. I’m fully supportive of these three (nominees). I think they’ll do an ideal job.” “I’m not a fan of strong mayor powers. I like the powers to rest with the people,” said Coun. Jason King at his first committee meeting. “Councillors should have as much opportunity to contribute and make decisions as much as possible, but on the other hand, I also appreciate the efficiency with which we need to move.” Although Morgan said he would strongly consider the results of the vote, councillors on the committee were reminded that even if they rejected one or more of the mayor’s selections, responsibility for the appointments would still rest with him. “I did receive that question earlier, and the answer to that was, it would be back in the mayor’s hands,” explained Deputy Mayor Corrine Rahman who chairs SPPC. Council supported the three chairs by a vote of 13-2, Trosow and Peloza opposed. Morgan maintained that seeking input was intended to make the process collaborative while meeting provincial requirements. “I’m happy to engage with any member of council on alternative processes in future years. My intention is to appoint these individuals for one year, not for a longer term, which would allow for continued discussion on this approach,” Morgan said.