The Greater Sudbury Police Service is facing intense criticism after witnesses say two officers shot and killed an injured bear cub without properly assessing whether the animal could be saved.
Local resident Anne Chadwick wrote a post on Thursday about coming across a black bear cub on the highway that had just been hit by a vehicle and abandoned.
She said she and another passing driver helped the bear to the side of the road, where she says it appeared both disoriented and with injuries to its front legs.
They called 911 for help, but she alleges that when two police officers arrived, they didn’t fully assess the cub’s condition but instead retrieved a rifle from their cruiser.
She said she was ordered to stand back while one of the officers repeatedly shot the bear. She said the cub was shot four times before it died.
Chadwick wrote that she was traumatized by watching the animal die in front of her and wondered whether the bear’s life could have been saved.
“He looked well enough that he could have been helped (obviously I'm not a vet and don't know for certain but neither were those police officers),” she wrote. “At the very least from what I've read he should have been tranquilized first.”
Her post has since been shared more than 5,800 times, prompting an outpouring of anger on social media.
The Greater Sudbury Police Service issued its own Facebook post about the incident on Thursday night, saying the officers had no other choice but to euthanize the animal.
“The bear cub was suffering, unable to move and struggling to breathe,” they wrote, adding that the officers “dispatched” the cub in order to end its pain.
The police service said the two officers would not have been able to safely handle or transport the injured animal, and though the Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry and city animal services were contacted, they were informed that neither agency could come to the scene.
“This is not a situation that any officer wants to be in and the Police Service attempted to find an alternative before the Officers made the decision to dispatch the cub,” the police wrote in their post.
Sudbury District MNRF spokesperson Yolanta Kowalski confirmed that her office did receive a call from the Sudbury police, but said it was “to pick up a dead bear cub from the side of a road.” She said since the ministry isn't responsible for the removal of dead wildlife, staff advised police to contact the City of Sudbury’s animal control services.
The Greater Sudbury Police Service’s Sgt. Terry Rumford defended the officers’ decision.
"I think we have to remember that these are judgement calls that officers have to make on a moment’s notice. Further, we are not equipped as a police service to transport bears,” he told CTV Northern Ontario.
He added that the police service would be reviewing the incident.
“With these types of incidents where there is community displeasure over certain incidents, we do what is called ‘administration reviews’ and we are in the process of doing that now," he said.
With a report from CTV Northern Ontario’s Molly Frommer
