Justice O'Bonsawin on the 'evolution' of and challenges facing Canada's top court
Marking one month as a judge on the Supreme Court of Canada, Michelle O'Bonsawin, speaks with Evan Solomon about why she wants people to see her as a judge first and the first Indigenous justice to sit on Canada's highest bench, second.
In the interview, O'Bonsawin also discusses the changing makeup as well as the politicization of the Supreme Court of Canada, and the legal challenges facing courts and the country's justice system writ large.
Below is a full transcript of the interview airing Sunday on CTV's Question Period. The transcript has been edited for clarity.
Evan Solomon: It is an absolute pleasure to welcome you to the program. Thank you so much for sitting down with us.
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "Thank you very much."
Evan Solomon: I want to start with something you said when you appeared at your question and answer session with parliamentarians. Let me just read it to you. You said, this is back in August, ‘I'm a judge first and an Indigenous person and a mother and a Franco Ontarian afterwards.’ I'm a judge first. Was that an intentional comment that you made given all the news about you is you are an historic first as the first Indigenous person on the bench?
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "Absolutely. Because I think what's important for people to know is judges on our court, we're impartial. And the question is, 'Well is she going to be biased because she's an Indigenous person when it comes to Indigenous matters that will come before the court?' So I was, I guess I would say strategic when I answered the question to say that I'm a judge first because I am impartial.
"But as the first Indigenous judge to be named to the Court, I think it's important for those to understand that I have my own background that's relevant to me as a Franco Ontarian and an Indigenous woman and I bring that view to the Court that is unique."
Evan Solomon: But it's interesting that you wanted to send that signal. Was there, or is there any perceived pressure as a first? … Is there any perceived pressure that now you represent a certain community, now you have to represent and to kind of cross that line into almost an activist position?
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "Well, of course. I think it's always a question: 'Is she going to be our spokesperson on the bench?' That's one of the issues that everyone's talking about. What I can say is I'm going to do the best that I can with regard to the files that are brought to the Court. I do fall under a microscope as being one of the first, but at the end of the day, I'm impartial and I'm going to base my decision on what's presented."
Evan Solomon: Is it also a bit awkward that you even get asked these questions? Frankly because it's like 'Oh, you didn't ask the person of Irish background if they're … so it's like, 'Why do I have to make sure that I have to strategically say my biases won't in any way distort the views, but you didn't ask him that?' Is that part of the problem?
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "Oh, absolutely. I think so. Because at the end of the day, if you're a man sitting on a case where it involves women's rights, is there a bias on that front, right? So of course that's a question that has to be asked."
Evan Solomon: I guess the other question is what took so long. The first woman was appointed in 1982, the first Jewish justice in 1970. The first person of colour just in the last year, now the first Indigenous person on the Court. What took so long? And what will change because we now have a court that reflects our country significantly more accurately than it used to?
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "I really don't know what the answer is. I think that there's been an evolution in our society where people want to look at a bench that resembles themselves. I think there's been a lot of activism by the different groups, so that may be it. I'm really unsure, but it's nice to see variety on the bench."
Evan Solomon: It is nice to see a bench that reflects the country. What is the biggest challenge, I mean the Supreme Court is kind of this awesome institution. People are kind of nervous of it, people are nervous to speak to you now, right?... What's the biggest challenge facing the court?
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "I think access to justice is always something that's out there. I think, hopefully, there's been an evolution because of the pandemic. So now that we have electronic means to hook into the Court, I'm hoping that's better. One of the challenges we face in every court level, are self-represented litigants, because it's difficult for them, and for us to deal with those types of issues."
Evan Solomon: The other issue for the Court and this goes back to when Beverley McLachlin was the chief, is the politicization of courts. You see it in the United States all the time. How concerned are you about the politicization of the courts -- that people are confused that the courts are going to start bleeding into areas which is really the jurisdiction of elected politicians?
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "I said this during my question period. We have totally separate roles, we're not like other countries. We’re unique. We have a system that was put in place in 2016 for the nomination of the different candidates. So, it's not a party-based type of nomination that comes through. I think we're quite different from the others and I don't think that's our role. Let the politicians do their job and we'll do ours."
Evan Solomon: Although, you see the politicization of the Bank of Canada, like this is happening now. The Court is fodder for political debate in which, I guess, it's not bad that the Court's decisions are debated?
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "Yeah, at the end of the day, we're independent and I would definitely say we don't fall in the realm as you see in other countries."
Evan Solomon: One of the issues that you've talked about is over incarceration rates of Indigenous Canadians, of people of colour, Black Canadians specifically. What is at the core of that? Like when you've looked at this, you you've been in the legal system, is it straight up systemic, institutionalized racism?
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "I think there's a mix of different things. I think there's society issues that come into play. You have all the impact of intergenerational trauma caused by residential schools, so there are social issues related to that. And that's led to really high numbers of incarceration of Indigenous people.
"We're less than five per cent of the population, but when you look at Dr. (Ivan) Zinger (the Correctional Investigator of Canada’s) last report, I think Indigenous women were close to 50 per cent and men over 30 per cent. So, it's ridiculous to be such a small part of society, but be such a large number in the incarceration rates.
Evan Solomon: There's a concept that a lot of Canadians may not be familiar with. Some will be, but you said you're a strong proponent of talking about the Gladue principles, which means taking into account the backgrounds of Indigenous peoples and personal backgrounds in terms of their incarceration. Why is that so important? And how does that function?
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "Well, I think it's really important. It was an amendment brought in by the Government of Canada in response to the high incarceration rates in the mid 90s. And unfortunately, the courts haven't always been consistent on how to apply these. So when an Indigenous person comes up for sentencing, the trial judge is supposed to consider the individual background of the individual.
"Unfortunately, at times, it's not a consistent use. And we've seen that... So I'm hoping there's going to be an improvement, the more that I and others talk about the need for judges to be cognizant of that."
Evan Solomon: Now, part of your background was in mental health. There's a big discussion about mental health going on. But when it comes to crimes, how does the system balance mental health because you know… There's some criticism that views that as a 'soft on crime and hard on victims.' How do we account for a mental health crisis, but still make people responsible for actions that they've taken?
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "I think that's why we created the forensic mental health system. So when you have someone who has been found not criminally responsible, unfit to stand trial, they go onto a parallel system called forensic mental health, which is different from what we see in the regular incarceration with the parole board.
"So you have a review board that looks at what kind of privileges these individuals should get, because sometimes, what people don't realize is when you've been found NCR (not criminally responsible) you could be in the forensic mental health system much longer than if you did a sentence of two years less a day. And it's all about improving their mental health, so that they're not a risk to society and to themselves."
Evan Solomon: Justice, just before I let you go, I mean, this is a daunting task. You mentioned this in in front of parliamentarians: You're a mom, you've got a life. How are you handling the ascension to the Court, the historic pressures, the amount of work that you probably are taking on? Is it a daunting task?
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "It is, but I have to say I've been quite fortunate. My family has been very supportive all along. I did my PhD while sitting as a full-time judge, so I'm good at juggling a schedule. And I don't sleep a lot. So there you go."
Evan Solomon: That was what I was wondering because your career is remarkable… Just last thing, the thing you're most looking forward to, or the thing you're most trepidatious about?
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "I'm really looking forward to writing my first decision. Of course, that's the most exciting thing. But also nervous about it, because it's a daunting task to write your first decision for the Supreme Court of Canada. So I think it's a mix of both sides of it."
Evan Solomon: And that could be maybe a year away, right?
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "I don't know."
Evan Solomon: Justice O'Bonsawin, what a pleasure to have you here. Thank you so much for taking time.
Michelle O'Bonsawin: "Thank you. I appreciate it."
The final week of hearings at the Public Order Emergency Commission is set to be a blockbuster one, as Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, a trio of his top staffers, and several members of cabinet are set to take the stand. Ahead of this last phase of testimony, here's a comprehensive recap of the key moments from the last five weeks.
The federal government's fall economic update makes it clear that while the deficit is declining, the risk that Canada enters into a recession is rising.
Members of Parliament—many dressed in black—returned to Ottawa on Thursday to take part in a 'special session' commemorating Queen Elizabeth II and marking the accession to the throne of King Charles III. The House of Commons held this historic opportunity to allow MPs to pay tribute ahead of Monday's national commemorations.
Pierre Poilievre is the new leader of the Conservative Party of Canada, securing victory on the first ballot after a record-setting and divisive leadership campaign. After a seven-month campaign, the long-time MP and former cabinet minister from Ontario won the election decisively. Securing support across the country, he told party members they are now 'one party serving one country.'
History was made on Oct. 13 with the launch of the Public Order Emergency Commission's public hearings in Ottawa, looking into the federal government's use of the Emergencies Act to bring last winter's 'Freedom Convoy' protests to an end. CTVNews.ca breaks down everything you need to know.
Don Martin: After a long final day on the Emergencies Act inquiry stand, it's convoy zero, Trudeau won
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau gambled just by showing up. And he appears to have won in the court of reasonable public opinion, Don Martin writes in an exclusive column for CTVNews.ca.
By declaring even the kitchen a fire hazard and health risk to continued service, the very kitchen where Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, his family and his visitors have been catered to remotely for seven years, the National Capital Commission has officially mothballed the estate and nailed an unofficial demolition order on the gates. This is not a lamentable development, Don Martin writes in an exclusive column for CTVNews.ca.
He may not have seen the potential threat when truckers rolled toward Ottawa last January, but Prime Minister Justin Trudeau cannot miss the risk of Freedom Convoy fallout he now faces, contributor Don Martin writes in an exclusive column for CTVNews.ca.
There's been a 20-year series of middleweight clashes in the parliamentary fight club - Chretien vs. Day, Martin vs. Harper, Harper vs. Mulcair, Trudeau vs. O'Toole - but nothing comes close to the slugfest now raging between Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.
The next premier of Alberta could well make Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre look like a right-wing lightweight, Don Martin writes in an exclusive column for CTVNews.ca.
ANALYSIS & INSIGHTS
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
The Canadian men’s national team are losing 3-1 in their FIFA World Cup match against Croatia on Sunday, a game where they must pick up at least one point or risk elimination. CTVNews.ca will follow the match live.
Protesters angered by strict anti-virus measures called for China's powerful leader to resign, an unprecedented rebuke as authorities in at least eight cities struggled to suppress demonstrations Sunday that represent a rare direct challenge to the ruling Communist Party.
With a cost estimate of $4.38 billion, remediation of the Giant Mine, one of the most contaminated sites in Canada, is also expected to be the most expensive federal environmental cleanup in the country's history.
A peer reviewed study assessing over 800 elderly women has found that flavonoids -- a naturally occurring substance found in beverages such as black and green tea -- could lead to notable health benefits.
Edmonton transit drivers are sharing images of what they are seeing on buses and the LRT on a sometimes daily basis in the hopes it will push the city to hire more transit peace officers.
'Calling a spade a spade': Foreign affairs minister signals tougher stance on China in new Indo-Pacific Strategy
The federal government has unveiled its long-awaited Indo-Pacific Strategy, which details a decade of plans for investment and partnerships in the region, and signals a tougher stance on China going forward.
Federal Health Minister Jean-Yves Duclos says the previously announced one million units of imported kids' pain relievers are starting to arrive on pharmacy shelves, while an additional 500,000 units have been ordered and are expected over the next few weeks.
After four scoreless matches in its men's World Cup history, Alphonso Davies scores Canada's first men's World Cup goal against Croatia.
Canada won its first Davis Cup title on Sunday, beating Australia behind victories from Denis Shapovalov and Felix Auger-Aliassime. Montreal's Auger-Aliassime beat Australia's Alex de Minaur 6-4, 6-3 on Sunday to clinch Canada's first Davis Cup championship. Shapovalov, from Richmond Hill, Ont., won Canada's first singles match -- 6-2, 6-4 over Thanasi Kokkinakis -- on Sunday.
Alcohol and speed were factors in a tragic collision that killed three junior hockey players in B.C.'s Lower Mainland last year, according to a coroner's report.
The City of Montreal will pay more than $3 million to hundreds of protestors whose rights were violated by city police. The settlement will end eight long-running class action lawsuits against the city that allege participants in six protests were illegally arrested or detained by police and were unable to exercise other fundamental rights.
As hospitals in Ottawa and across Ontario deal with an overflow of patients, the Ontario government is cutting some of the fees it pays to doctors who provide online care.
Canada is importing more children’s medication amid an unprecedented surge in demand, but the head of the Ontario Pharmacists’ Association warns that the supply will still need to be rationed if it’s going to last.
The federal government says it is investing $39.4 million to support Indigenous languages in the territories.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau made an appearance on Friday's episode of "Canada's Drag Race: Canada vs. the World" to offer the contestants words of inspiration before the main challenge.
Russian forces shell eastern, southern Ukraine as utility crews scramble to restore power, water and heat
Russian forces struck several areas in eastern and southern Ukraine early Sunday as utility crews scrambled to restore power, water and heating with the onset of snow and frigid temperatures, while civilians continued to leave the southern city of Kherson because of the devastation wreaked by recent attacks and of fears of more ahead.
The head of Ukraine's state-run nuclear energy firm said on Sunday there were signs that Russian forces might be preparing to leave the vast Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant which they seized in March soon after their invasion.
Fleeing shelling, civilians on Saturday streamed out of the southern Ukrainian city whose recapture they had celebrated just weeks earlier as the country remembered a Stalin-era famine and sought to ensure that Russia's war in Ukraine doesn't deprive others worldwide of its vital food exports.
This is a dress with a story, and Elizabeth Emanuel wants to tell it.
Sheetal Deo was shocked when she got a letter from her Queens apartment building's co-op board calling her Diwali decoration "offensive" and demanding she take it down.
Search teams pulled the body of a young girl from her family home on Sunday as they dug through mud for a second day in the search for people still missing after an enormous landslide on the Italian resort island of Ischia.
Federal officials are set to make an announcement today in Vancouver about Canada's long-promised Indo-Pacific strategy. A media advisory from Global Affairs Canada says the Indo-Pacific region is key for Canada's economic growth, prosperity and security.
After six weeks, more than 70 witnesses, and the submission of more than 7,000 documents into evidence, the public hearing portion of the Public Order Emergency Commission wrapped up on Friday.
Preventable diseases like measles could follow trends seen elsewhere in the world and spread quickly in Canada due to a drop in routine vaccinations during the COVID-19 pandemic, say pediatricians who are urging parents to ensure their kids are fully immunized.
Friends of a man who died waiting for care inside the Moncton Hospital’s ER waiting room this past week held a demonstration Saturday outside the building, demanding answers and action.
NASA's Orion capsule entered an orbit stretching tens of thousands of kilometres around the moon Friday, as it neared the halfway mark of its test flight.
Several people in Manitoba got a clear look at a celestial sight Thursday night. A meteor was caught streaking across the sky in the province, with cameras catching it in Winnipeg and other areas north of the city.
New Twitter owner Elon Musk said Thursday that he is granting 'amnesty' for suspended accounts, which online safety experts predict will spur a rise in harassment, hate speech and misinformation.
Oscar, Golden Globe and two-time Grammy winning singer-actress Irene Cara, who starred and sang the title cut from the 1980 hit movie 'Fame' and then belted out the era-defining hit 'Flashdance ... What a Feeling' from 1983's 'Flashdance,' has died. She was 63.
Matt Hancock, the U.K's scandal-prone former health secretary, is seeking an unlikely form of redemption Sunday: attempting to win 'I'm a Celebrity... Get Me Out of Here!' -- a grueling, often gruesome reality show set in the Australian jungle.
Canadian banks are set to reveal how they're faring in the lead up to a possible recession as they report quarterly earnings this week. As central banks raise interest rates to slow inflation, economic fears have held bank stocks back compared with the overall market, so analysts will be looking to see how well set up the sector is before an expected slowdown next year.
Pretty much everyone hates Airbnb cleaning fees -- those pesky charges tacked on to your vacation rental bill that supposedly cover the costs to get the place ready for the next visitors. Travelers don't like the expense, and hosts don't like charging them, either.
Worker paycheques in the province that once led the country in wage growth have flatlined, but experts say the double whammy of inflation and labour shortages mean Alberta businesses are poised to face a reckoning on wages soon.
While working along the Lake Erie shoreline last weekend, a photographer from Ingersoll captured something unexpected. 'It took me hours to go through them all but I found a couple I really liked and that one stood out,' said Cody Evans.
Flossie, at the age of almost 27 -- which is the feline equivalent of being 120 human years old, according to Guinness World Records -- has been crowned the world's oldest living cat.
Viewing parties are planned across the country today as soccer fans gear up to watch Canada's World Cup match against Croatia -- a do-or-die game for the team in its first tournament appearance in 36 years.
Day 7 at World Cup 2022: Magic Messi saves Argentina; France reaches knockouts; Poland, Australia stay alive
The World Cup action in Qatar continued with Tunisia, Australia, Poland, Saudi Arabia, France, Denmark, Mexico, and Argentina all playing. CTVNews.ca takes a look at everything you need to know from Day 7 of the tournament.
Ford Motor Co. is recalling more than 634,000 SUVs worldwide because a cracked fuel injector can spill fuel or leak vapours onto a hot engine and cause fires.
Tesla drivers will now be able to use the full self-driving beta program in Toronto's downtown after the company removed a geofence prohibiting its use.
Buying your first car can be as exciting as it is daunting. Whether you’re buying a car off the lot from a dealership or purchasing a car in a private sale, contributor Christopher Liew shares in an exclusive column for CTVNews.ca a few basic tips that you should always keep in mind.