Federal Court of Appeal: Canada not constitutionally obligated to bring home suspected ISIS fighters
The Government of Canada has won its appeal and will not be legally forced to repatriate four Canadian men from prisons in Northeast Syria.
A Federal Court of Appeal decision has ruled that "The Government of Canada is not constitutionally obligated or otherwise obligated at law to repatriate the respondents. However these reasons should not be taken to discourage the Government of Canada from making efforts on its own to bring about that result."
The federal government suspects the men left Canada to join the Islamic State group during the Syrian civil war.
The men have been detained for years in Kurdish prisons, following the collapse of the ISIS. But none of them have been charged nor has evidence of terrorist activities been presented in court.
Canada, along with other countries has also faced pressure from the United Nations and human rights group to bring their nationals home.
At the crux of the case known as Canada v. BOLOH (Bring Our Loved Ones Home) was a debate over Section 6 of the Charter which states "every citizen of Canada, has the right to enter, remain and leave Canada."
NO CHARTER GUARANTEE OF RIGHT TO RETURN
Lawyers representing the detainees argued that a "right to enter" means a "right to return" - but the panel of three appellate judges disagreed. In its analysis of past legal decisions, the appeal court wrote that the Charter protects against exile and banishment but "offers no encouragement for the idea that Subsection 6(1) includes a right to be returned to Canada."
The appeal panel acknowledged that starting in 2011, the government had repeatedly warned Canadians not to enter Syria due to a brutal civil war. Canada had also closed its embassy in Damascus in 2012 and warned citizens that it could not provide assistance in the country.
The ruling also found that exposing officials to "personal danger" to bring back a person detained in a territory controlled by a non-state entity falls "outside the outer edges" of the charter. The Canadians are held in prisons operated by the Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria.
The decision from the Federal Court of Appeal overturns an earlier decision by Federal Court Justice Henry Brown in January of this year.
Lawrence Greenspon, who represents three of the four detainees, said that he will review the decision and weigh appealing to the Supreme Court.
"We felt the decision of by Federal Court Justice Brown was one we thought was on good legal ground... and we're considering whether or not to send an application for leave to the Supreme Court of Canada," said Greenspon in an interview with CTV National News.
PERPETUATING “ARBITRARY DETENTION AND TORTURE”
Sally Lane, whose son Jack Letts is the only detainee identified in the court documents said in a text message that she was "too downhearted" after finding out about the decision on Wednesday afternoon.
In previous interviews, Lane says her son converted to Islam as a teenager and travelled to Syria in 2014 to help fellow Muslims. She says Letts is not a terrorist and she has not heard from her son since 2019.
Lane did express her emotions on social media, saying the Federal Court of Appeal has made a "clear choice to perpetuate the arbitrary detention and torture of my son and the other Canadians."
"The decision is nothing but victim blaming and narrow legalese that stands in utter contempt of human rights law and fails to rise to the challenge of the moment," Lane's statement posted on Twitter goes on to say.
CANADIAN WOMEN AND CHILDREN STILL STRANDED IN CAMPS
This appellate decision does not impact the fate of Canadian women and children that the government has agreed to repatriate. In April, 14 women and children were brought back from Al-Roj detention camp, but five people with Edmonton roots were left behind.
Greenspon said that Global Affairs Canada is committed to bringing them home. A Quebec woman and her six children are also waiting to be brought back after delays in processing the mother's security assessment.
Another group of mothers are currently suing the federal government for repatriation. Canada has agreed to bring home their children, who are the offspring of Canadian fathers who may have died or disappeared in Syria, but not their foreign mothers.
Several women the government suspected of marrying ISIS fighters face terrorism related charges or have been put on a terrorism peace bond. Since their return these Canadians have been placed under strict conditions and placed in de-radicalization programs.
IN DEPTH

ANALYSIS What do the policies Poilievre's party passed say about the Conservatives' future?
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre spent the summer speaking about housing affordability, a core focus that attendees at the party's Quebec City convention were quick to praise him for. But by the end of the weekend, delegates opted to instead pass policies on contentious social issues. What does that say about the Conservatives' future?
Justin Trudeau and wife Sophie Gregoire Trudeau separating, after 18 years of marriage
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his wife are separating after 18 years of marriage, and while they plan to co-parent their children, Sophie Gregoire Trudeau will no longer be considered the prime minister's spouse in any official capacity.
'A very retro, family-oriented message': New ads aim to reframe Poilievre
With a steady lead in the polls and a healthy war chest of political donations, the Conservative Party is rolling out a trio of new advertisements that are being viewed as aiming to redefine and soften Pierre Poilievre's image and messaging.
Trudeau's new House leader wants question period to become an hour Canadians watching can be proud of
If you've tuned in to question period and wondered if that is really how the elected member of Parliament representing you in Ottawa should be acting, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's new House leader is trying to change that.
Seven rookies promoted, most ministers reassigned in major Trudeau cabinet shuffle
In a major cabinet shuffle on Wednesday, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau promoted seven rookies to his front bench, dropped seven ministers, and reassigned the majority of cabinet roles. In a ceremony at Rideau Hall, Trudeau orchestrated one of, if not the most consequential reconfigurations to his cabinet since 2015.
Opinion

OPINION Don Martin: Canada is back on the world stage. And mostly alone.
Justin Trudeau got one promise right: Canada is back on the world stage. Sadly, it’s for all the wrong reasons, writes Don Martin in an exclusive opinion column for CTVNews.ca.
opinion Don Martin: Nice try, Prime Minister Trudeau. But it's too little, too late
Nice try, prime minister. But likely too little, too late and too transparently desperate to serve as a realistic government-salvage strategy, writes Don Martin in an exclusive opinion column for CTVNews.ca.
opinion Don Martin: Poilievre doesn't feel your pain, but he's sure good at communicating it
Probably no other leader, including Justin Trudeau, has landed in a party leadership with less real-world work experience than Pierre Poilievre, says Don Martin in a column for CTVNews.ca. But Poilievre's an able communicator, and this weekend's Conservative convention is a golden opportunity for him to sell himself as PM-in-waiting.
opinion Don Martin: Who will step up to have 'The Talk' with Trudeau?
Ego and vanity are a potent combination in leadership politics, and in his exclusive column for CTVNews.ca, Don Martin writes this condition is infecting Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's mindset as he seems deadly serious about seeking re-election in 2025.
opinion Don Martin: I've never seen anything quite like the control-everything regime of Trudeau's government
Voters in four byelections delivered status quo results on Monday that show, if you squint hard enough, that the severely tainted Liberal brand has staying power while the Conservatives aren’t resurging enough to threaten as a majority-government-in-waiting, writes Don Martin in an exclusive column for CTVNews.ca.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy set to arrive in Ottawa for first visit since war
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy is set to arrive in the national capital for his first official visit to Canada since Russia launched a full-scale invasion in February 2022.
Law firm awarded $4.5 million contract for David Johnston foreign interference probe
A Toronto-based law firm was awarded a nearly $4.5 million contract to work on former special rapporteur David Johnston's ill-fated foreign interference probe.
U.S., India talking about Canada murder, no 'special exemption': Biden adviser
The U.S. is in touch with Indians at high levels after Ottawa said Indian government agents had links to the murder of a Sikh separatist leader in Canada, and Washington is giving India no 'special exemption' in the matter, U.S. national security adviser Jake Sullivan said on Thursday.
B.C. First Nation research finds 158 child deaths at four facilities
An investigation into unmarked graves and missing children by British Columbia's Sto:lo Nation has revealed at least 158 deaths, most of them at an Indigenous hospital.
Is a 'no-tipping' policy ready to be adopted by Canadian restaurants?
As Canadians report their frustrations with 'out-of-control' tipping culture, some wonder whether it is time to remove the option to tip at restaurants and is it even possible amid rising food costs?
Man admits to fatally poisoning Toronto toddler's breakfast cereal in 'obsessive' plot against married woman
A Toronto man has admitted to fatal poisoning of a toddler's breakfast cereal at a Scarborough residence in 2021 as part of an "obsessive" plot against a married woman.
'I don't know when we'll go': Travel plans upended amid fraying Canada-India ties
Members of the Indo-Canadian community are reeling after the Indian government suspended visa services for citizens of Canada, upending travel plans for those set on visiting the country but now caught in the crossfire of a diplomatic blowup.
'It was a mistake': Ford reversing Ontario government's decision to open Greenbelt
Premier Doug Ford said he will be reversing his government’s decision to open up the Greenbelt to developers, calling the controversial land removals a “mistake.”
'They were good men': Colleague remembers 4 B.C. wildland firefighters killed in head-on collision near Kamloops
A team leader at Tomahawk Ventures, a company contracted by the province to fight forest fires, is remembering four colleagues who died when their pickup truck crashed into a semi truck on the Trans-Canada Highway near Kamloops early Tuesday morning.