Federal appeals court says it can't hear NDP case on satellite-office expenses
NDP delegates gather on the party convention floor in Ottawa, Friday, February 16, 2018.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand
The Canadian Press
Published Wednesday, February 20, 2019 2:08PM EST
OTTAWA -- The Federal Court of Appeal says it can't intervene in a case where more than five dozen NDP MPs were ordered to repay $2.7 million in expenses the House of Commons says was actually for partisan purposes.
The decision is a blow to the NDP, which is already struggling financially and has been trying to get the courts to agree the 2014 decision by the House of Commons administration committee was politically motivated and illegal.
The Commons committee ruled that 68 NDP MPs had to repay $2.7 million claimed as expenses for office staff, money the board said was actually used to subsidize party offices in Montreal, Quebec City and Toronto.
The NDP was seeking a judicial review to overturn the order from the House of Commons' board of internal economy, and the board argued the courts don't have jurisdiction to overturn the decision because of parliamentary privilege.
A federal judge sided with the NDP and was allowing the judicial review, but the Federal Court of Appeal is striking down the judicial review applications, saying courts have no jurisdiction to hear them.
The original price tag for the NDP was $2.7 million but some MPs have been able to prove that their expenses were for legitimate parliamentary work.