CP analysis: Money didn't guarantee victory in 2015 election
Conservative Leader Stephen Harper looks on as Nicole Ropp throws money on the counter as they illustrate how Liberal tax hikes will affect Canadians during a Conservative campaign event at an apple farm in Waterloo, Ont., Monday, Oct. 12, 2015. (Jonathan Hayward / THE CANADIAN PRESS)
Jordan Press and Joan Bryden, The Canadian Press
Published Sunday, April 3, 2016 3:01PM EDT
Last Updated Sunday, April 3, 2016 5:06PM EDT
OTTAWA -- Money can't buy you votes.
Or so it would seem, according to campaign financial reports filed with Elections Canada by the men and women who were seeking a House of Commons seat in last fall's federal election.
More often than not, the biggest spenders did not win on Oct. 19, an analysis by The Canadian Press indicates.
And while spending big bucks didn't necessarily guarantee victory, not spending enough to at least stay competitive with rival candidates was an almost certain path to defeat, the analysis shows.
Of the top 100 spenders in the election, 57 failed in their election bids, with 12 of those losing to a competitor who also cracked the top 100.
The results among the top 50 spenders were even worse, with about three-fifths of them -- 31 candidates in all -- running unsuccessfully. Of those, six lost to another candidate in the top 50.
The analysis is based on expenses reported by candidates that counted as part of their legal spending limits. It did not include personal and other expenses -- like gas and mileage for a personal vehicle, child care or thank-you receptions for volunteers -- which must be reported to Elections Canada but don't count against the spending cap.
The analysis may help explain why the marathon 11-week campaign came down to a battle between the better-resourced Liberals and Conservatives, with the NDP and Greens squeezed out.
On average, Conservative candidates spent $90,665, outpacing the average $71,660 spent by Liberals. The average New Democrat candidate spent just $54,404 while the average Green spent a measly $12,642.
University of Manitoba political scientist Royce Koop said there's no doubt money can help a candidate win, particularly in a close-fought riding.
NDP MP Kennedy Stewart, for instance, spent almost $180,600 on his campaign in Burnaby South, while his Liberal opponent, Adam Pankratz, spent $33,902. Pankratz lost by a margin of just one percentage point, a result Koop suggests might have been different had the Liberal been more competitive financially.
"Most Canadians vote with the party in mind, so local spending and local volunteers are going to have a much more substantial influence in closer races," said Koop, who studied the spending habits of local campaigns in the last election.
"If you run a good campaign, well-funded campaign, well-staffed, you're going to be able to get just ahead of your opponent and it turns out Canadian elections are getting more competitive. We're seeing more of these competitive races, so the importance of local campaigns and local spending and local campaign workers has become more important."
Candidate spending limits for the 2015 campaign varied from riding to riding, based on geographic size and population -- from a high of $279,227 in Kootenay-Columbia to a low of $169,928 in Egmont. Under new election rules imposed by the previous Conservative government, the spending caps for the lengthy campaign were more than twice what they would have been for a more typical five-week federal contest.
That was widely seen as benefiting the Conservatives, whose riding associations across the country had amassed much deeper war chests. A previous analysis of electoral district associations' 2014 financial returns found Tory associations ended the year with net assets totalling more than $19 million -- more than the riding associations of the Liberals, New Democrats, Greens and Bloc Quebecois combined.
Yet the analysis of the more than 1,500 candidate spending reports filed thus far suggests few took advantage of the increased limits.
Combined, candidates for the Liberals, Conservatives, NDP and Greens -- the parties which ran full or nearly full slates in all 338 ridings across the country -- were entitled to spend $296 million. Yet their actual spending fell far short: just under $63.1 million in total.
Even adding in the personal and other expenses, total spending amounts to $72.6 million.
All candidates were required to file their financial reports by Feb. 19 but many were granted an extension. Some 200 have yet to file.
Analysis of the reports filed thus far further suggests that the Liberals and Conservatives ran fewer Potemkin campaigns -- where candidates had their names on the ballot but few resources to mount a serious challenge -- than the NDP or, especially, the Greens.
The returns show the Conservatives had the highest number of candidates -- 127 -- who spent over $100,000, followed by the Liberals with 73, the NDP with 47 and the Greens with just 10.
On the flip side, more than 180 Greens spent less than $10,000, including about 50 who spent less than $1,000 -- more than the low spenders of the Liberals, Conservatives and New Democrats combined. Green party Leader Elizabeth May spent the most of any leader, almost maxing out the amount she was allowed to spend in her B.C. riding, but was the only Green elected.
"If parties have money to spend, they'll concentrate it in winnable ridings, not ridings where they're going to have a runaway victory and not ridings where they're going to lose," Koop said.
TOP 10 CONSERVATIVE SPENDERS
Stella Ambler (lost Mississauga-Lakeshore): $221,077.62
Abdul Abdi (lost Ottawa West--Nepean): $203,049.92
Larry Maguire (won Brandon--Souris): $202,921.60
John Weston (lost West Vancouver--Sunshine Coast--Sea to Sky Country): $199,351.34
Ed Holder (lost London West): $195,701.45
Dean Drysdale (lost Cloverdale--Langley City): $194,990.79
Parm Gill (lost Brampton North): $194,412.67
Bal Gosal (lost Brampton Centre): $194,194.83
Erinn Broshko (lost Vancouver Granville): $193,526.14
Douglas Horne (lost Coquitlam--Port Coquitlam): $193,315.18
TOP 10 LIBERAL SPENDERS
Lloyd Longfield (won Guelph): $211,040.55
Catherine McKenna (won Ottawa Centre): $195,079.38
Andrew Leslie (won Orleans): $193,786.62
Kent Hehr (won Calgary Centre) $191,350.01
Chrystia Freeland (won University-Rosedale): $187,572.60
Chandra Arya (won Nepean): $180,068.97
Bill Morneau (won Toronto Centre): $178,162.01
Pam Goldsmith-Jones (won West Vancouver--Sunshine Coast--Sea to Sky Country): $177,892.58
Harjit Sajjan (won Vancouver South): $167,786.06
Sukh Dhaliwal (won Surrey--Newton) $165,371.15
TOP 10 NDP SPENDERS
Murray Rankin (won Victoria): $214,728.52
Paul Dewar (lost Ottawa Centre): $201,972.04
Linda McQuaig (lost Toronto Centre): $194,807.01
Kennedy Stewart (won Burnaby South): $180,599.07
Craig Scott (lost Toronto--Danforth): $177,475.25
Megan Leslie (lost Halifax): $169,960.62
Mira Oreck (lost Vancouver Granville): $167,662.48
Bill Sundhu (lost Kamloops--Thompson--Cariboo): $158,523.06
Olivia Chow (lost Spadina--Fort York): $157,112.21
Jennifer Hollett (lost University--Rosedale): $155,181.47