A biology class that tested nine different samples of fish sold in sushi restaurants and grocery stores in southwestern Ontario was shocked to learn seven of the samples were mislabelled as different species of fish.
Even worse, one of the samples included a tiny louse that feeds on human skin.
The alarming discovery was made last week by a molecular biology class led by Jennifer McDonald, a professor at Fanshawe College in London, Ont.
“I knew about fish fraud as existing, but I wasn’t aware of just how big of a problem it really is,” McDonald told CTVNews.ca on Friday. “Maybe we need to be more demanding of tighter regulations in our food so we really know what we are eating.”
The project began as a lesson in DNA barcoding. Students were tasked with picking up fish at sushi restaurants and grocery stores and bringing them to class. The samples were collected from across the region, including Mississauga, London and the Muskoka region, and sent to a lab at Western University.
McDonald suspected some mislabelling. A study released last summer by ocean advocacy group Oceana Canada found that 44 per cent of seafood tested in five different cities were mislabelled. Similar studies conducted on the east and west coasts found the odds of mislabelled fish at around 50-50.
“So I figured it might be a little bit higher than what they found there. But this much?” McDonald said.
Of the nine samples, seven were mislabelled. The results included:
- Escolar, sometimes called “the laxative of the sea,” mislabelled as white tuna;
- Tilapia, a naturally white fish, mislabelled as red tuna, a red fish;
- Another tilapia sample mislabelled as red snapper
- Salmon sold in a grocery store containing a body louse;
- Yellowfin tuna mislabelled as albacore tuna;
- Rainbow trout mislabelled as Atlantic salmon;
- Coho salmon mislabelled as rainbow trout;
- Atlantic cod mislabelled as Pacific cod
Several of those findings raised serious alarm bells. Escolar contains an oily, indigestible substance named gempylotoxin that can lead to diarrhea, nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, and headache.
Eating escolar can also cause keriorrhoea, described as the “rectal passage of an oily yellow or orange substance” by the Canadian Food Inspection Agency. The CFIA says it “works to ensure that escolar is not misidentified or mislabelled when it is sold at the retail level.”
“It was just shocking to everybody,” McDonald said of the discovery.
WHITE FISH POTENTIALLY DYED RED
The fact that tilapia passed as red tuna was also concerning, considering the fact that tilapia is a white fish.
“There had to be some kind of colouring on it. Either it was from a natural source or artificial food colouring, I’m not sure,” McDonald said.
Then there was possibly the most disturbing discovery: a body louse found on a piece of salmon purchased in a grocery store. Body lice are about the size a sesame seed and are capable of passing along certain diseases. They survive by eating dead human skin.
McDonald suspects the louse may have landed on the salmon at some point in the supply chain.
“It is really surprising to find that. We hope that we’re not eating insects when we eat food,” she said.
The findings reflect a potential for very serious health concerns, especially for consumers with food-related allergies.
“We should be guaranteed that what we're seeing or what were told in a restaurant is what we’re actually being served,” McDonald said.
“And if we can’t guarantee that, as consumers, then how do we know we’re avoiding things we can’t eat in the first place?”
NEXT UP: CANNED TUNA, SCALLOPS
Despite the concerns, McDonald said she doesn’t blame sushi restaurants for mislabelled fish.
“I know at higher end sushi restaurants, they’re extremely talented at filleting fish,” she said. “At the average place that a student could afford to go -- probably not. They probably obtained the fish form their suppliers, deboned already, and it might’ve been sliced into serving style slices already … can they guarantee they know what they’re getting? I don’t think they can.”
The project was originally intended to be a fun, teachable moment for students. Moving forward, McDonald plans to test more types of fish and seafood, including canned tuna and scallops.
The professor shared the results of the experiment on Twitter in a thread expressing her shock and disgust. The thread has since been retweeted more than 6,000 times.
“I think it kind of reinforces this feeling everyone had,” McDonald said of the response, adding that many people shared stories of getting sick shortly after eating sushi.
She said the findings revealed “just how easily we’re misled.”