Russian embargo devastating farmers in one of poorest regions of Europe
Moldovan farmer Sergiu Calmac stands in his apple orchard in Harbovat, Moldova on Aug. 7, 2014. Two weeks before Russia banned most food from the West, it placed a similar embargo on produce closer to home, in Moldova, a small eastern European country seeking deeper ties with the European Union. Farmers there, in one of the poorest corners of Europe, are already feeling the pain, with some deciding not to harvest some of their fruit and vegetables at all this season. (AP Photo/Vitalie Plotnic)
Corneliu Rusnac and Vanessa Gera, The Associated Press
Published Tuesday, August 12, 2014 11:21AM EDT
HARBOVAT, Moldova -- Farmer Sergiu Calmac watches as row upon row of juicy red apples once destined for Russia ripen, fall to the ground and start to rot. Two weeks before Russia banned most food from the West, it placed a similar embargo on produce closer to home in Moldova, a small Eastern European country seeking deeper ties with the European Union.
Farmers here in one of the poorest corners of Europe are already feeling the pain, with some deciding not to harvest some of their fruit and vegetables at all this season. Calmac's predicament is one that other farmers across Europe and beyond can expect to some degree after Russia expanded the circle of countries targeted by its food embargoes.
"A weaker person than me would lose his mind, seeing how his work and investment are being lost," said Calmac, a 60-year-old who has spent the past 26 years as a farmer. "I have never had a situation like this."
In late July Russia banned foods from Moldova and Ukraine -- both former Soviet republics that the Kremlin wants to keep in its sphere of influence -- after they moved to deepen their political and economic ties with the EU. A ban on Polish fruits and vegetables soon followed as Warsaw called for sanctions against Moscow for its aggression in Ukraine. Last week Moscow took things further, banning most food imports from the West in retaliation for sanctions imposed as tensions mount over Ukraine.
The consequences of this geopolitical tit-for-tat are particularly painful in Moldova because it is already one of Europe's poorest countries, a place where the average monthly salary is only $300 (225 euros) and where 30 per cent of the GDP comes from remittances sent home by the 600,000 Moldovans -- from a nation of 4 million -- working abroad.
Prime Minister Iurie Leanca criticized the embargo, calling it "a violation of the principles of economic co-operation between Moldova and Russia," and promised some compensation to fruit farmers "within the limits of possibility."
Moldova, a largely agricultural country, depends heavily on its trade with Russia. Fruit was its largest export, with 90 per cent of its apples sent there before the ban. The lost revenue from apples alone is expected to reach $50 million, or three-quarters of a per cent of GDP. And while the government does not yet have an estimate for the overall loss, the situation will certainly be worse once other produce is factored in. Amid the political tensions, Russia has also hinted that some 300,000 Moldovan workers in Russia may no longer be welcome.
The disruptions to Moldova's economy also come at an extremely delicate time politically. Moldova has a pro-Russian separatist break-away region, Trans-Dniester, that longs to be united with Russia and which has put its army on alert amid the tensions in Ukraine.
The country also faces elections in November expected to determine whether it stays on its pro-Western course or if politicians friendlier to Moscow take over. Wedged between EU member Romania and Ukraine, Moldova has an electorate deeply divided over whether to grow more aligned with the West or Russia. If voters blame their pro-Western government for any new economic pain, it could shift that balance with lasting consequences.
"Should the economic effects be felt in Moldova with this embargo, not only would pro-Moscow parties use this to their advantage to try to keep Moldova in Moscow's orbit, but it would also have the effect of derailing or delaying Moldova's aspirations to be part of the European Union," said Stephen Nix, the director of the Eurasia program with the International Republican Institute, a pro-democracy organization based in Washington which conducts programming in Moldova.
In an interview at his picturesque and sprawling orchard in Harbovat, a village in southern Moldova, Calmac had only vague criticism for the country's leaders. "I realize that international relations in our region are complicated but the government could have put more effort into this," he said.
Instead, he is most concerned about how he will pay his 200 employees and repay 4 million Moldovan lei ($290,000) that he owes to pesticide companies. He is hoping that the companies will allow him to postpone his payments because repaying them on time seems unrealistic given the new market prices: Moldovan apples usually sell for $0.50 a kilogram. Now he stands to earn only $0.04 a kilogram from the juice-making factories that have become his only buyer. He expects to lose 3.5 million lei ($255,000), which was 75 per cent of his 2013 profit.
Calmac, who is also the head of a local agricultural co-operative, said matters would be even worse had its members not worked to diversify their production beyond just fruit and vegetables destined to Russia. They also grow cereal and sunflowers and together run a small canning plant where they process green peas and tomato paste.
It's a lesson others in the region have already learned in recent years due to previous bans by Russia at times of political tension.
Lithuania, for instance, reacted to a Russian ban on its food products last year with short-term food donations to charities -- and a longer-term drive to enter new markets in China, Australia and Brazil.
Poland, which was also targeted by bans in past years, has worked to secure new markets in Asia and elsewhere.
Still, the ban on its produce is expected to bite given that exported foods and agricultural products to Russia last year were worth $1.6 billion dollars. Much of the focus there has been on apples since Poland is the world's third largest apple exporter, with more than half of its production going to Russia before the ban.
As a result, the Kremlin's embargo has sparked a patriotic outpouring of support for apples which is turning them into nothing less than a symbol of freedom. Newspapers are calling on Poles to eat more apples, saying that could help partly offset the problem, pushing the agenda with articles on the many health benefits of the fruit.
President Bronislaw Komorowski has vowed to drink more Polish cider while his wife shared her recipe for apple pie with one of the tabloids last week. The recipe calls for "two kilograms of Polish apples."
Gera reported from Warsaw, Poland. Associated Press writers Alison Mutler in Bucharest, Romania, Monika Scislowska in Warsaw and Liudas Dapkus in Vilnius, Lithuania, also contributed to this report.