War for customers brewing if CIBC, TD don't reach deal on Aeroplan: analyst
Cards from CIBC, TD Bank and Aeroplan as shown in Montreal Thursday, June 27, 2013. (Ryan Remiorz / THE CANADIAN PRESS)
Published Tuesday, August 13, 2013 10:26AM EDT
Last Updated Tuesday, August 13, 2013 5:05PM EDT
TORONTO -- Loyalty credit card customers could soon find themselves being aggressively wooed if a proposed deal to allow both TD and CIBC to offer Aeroplan rewards cards doesn't succeed.
"We're definitely excited by all of the disruption that's occurring," said Linda Mantia, executive vice-president of cards and payment solutions at Royal Bank of Canada (TSX:RY), which offers the Avion Visa.
"I think it's causing a lot more people to think about their credit card ... We're very keen to have an opportunity to tell these clients our story and bring them onboard."
American Express Canada also said it plans to ramp up the marketing of its own rewards cards, which include several that allow users to earn Aeroplan points.
"We do see this as an opportunity to win over a lot more consumers onto the American Express brand," said David Barnes, the company's vice-president of advertising and communications.
Aimia (TSX:AIM), the company that operates the Aeroplan points system, announced Monday that TD (TSX:TD) will take over from CIBC as its main banking partner, but Aimia said it is still trying to work out a compromise with CIBC.
Aimia said Tuesday that it's possible both TD and CIBC will be offering cards with Aeroplan rewards points starting next year if the two banks can come up with an agreement.
Aimia CEO Rupert Duchesne told analysts that having both banks offering Aeroplan cards "would be an elegant solution that would be a win-win-win for us, TD, and CIBC."
Industrial Alliance Securities analyst Neil Linsdell said he doesn't think it's likely that TD will agree to a proposed deal that would see CIBC (TSX:CM) retain about half of the Aeroplan customers.
"If you're TD, do you want CIBC to be able to offer Aeroplan points to their credit card customers? Probably not," Linsdell said.
"This is the whole reason they inked this deal, to get exclusivity on this thing so they could really get their hooks into it."
Unless the banks work out a mutual agreement, that could mean a bumpy transition for Aeroplan holders with the CIBC Aeroplan cards to TD, said Linsdell.
It would create a prime opportunity for competitors like American Express and RBC to try to snatch up a larger share of the rewards card business.
"If you suddenly don't have a CIBC Aerogold Visa choice anymore and you're going to transition over to TD, maybe you're going to take this opportunity to re-evaluate," said Linsdell.
"Do I really need an Aeroplan affiliated card? Should I go with a cash-back card, instead?"
That could lead to an all-out war in the rewards card market that could give customers more choices as TD, CIBC, RBC and other competitors present comparable packages.
However, if CIBC completely stops offering Aeroplan products, that could mean customers who hold its Aventura rewards card would no longer be able to redeem their points for Aeroplan miles -- one of the "key benefits" of the program, said Linsdell.
During its second-quarter earnings call last May, RBC said it was poised to snag a larger share of the loyalty credit card market if CIBC does not renew its deal with Aimia.
"If there's any disruption in the marketplace, it will cause customers to re-evaluate their credit card and value propositions," David McKay, RBC's head of personal and commercial banking, told analysts.
"That point of re-evaluation is a significant opportunity for us to present our solution to a large number of Canadians who might not consider them otherwise."
Montreal-based Aimia, which began as division within Air Canada that managed frequent fliers points, has since expanded to handle other customer loyalty programs in various industries in several countries.
CIBC has partnered with Aeroplan for more than 20 years but that relationship is in flux as its current 10-year term agreement with Aimia comes to a close at the end of the year.
CIBC has declined to match an offer from rival TD Bank but it has proposed that it should keep half of current Aerogold customers who have other products with CIBC that earn Aeroplan miles, such as chequing accounts and mortgages.
The three parties said Monday that they were working towards an agreement by Aug. 26. However, if there's no compromise, Aimia has said it will go ahead with the TD plan.
After markets closed Monday, Aimia announced a second-quarter net loss of $415.2 million or $2.43 per share, compared with a profit of $35 million or 19 cents per share a year ago, as it took a hit related to changes in the Aeroplan program.