New mortgage rules cooling home sales Canada-wide: report
A dump truck gets set to dump clean fill at a new housing development in Oakville, Ont. on Aug.26, 2011. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Richard Buchan)
Published Monday, September 24, 2012 10:53AM EDT
Last Updated Monday, September 24, 2012 10:31PM EDT
OTTAWA -- Canada's housing market appears to be cooling across the board in the face of tighter mortgage rules that affect many first-time buyers of modest means, a new analysis from the Conference Board shows.
The think-tank's snapshot of resales for August shows a widespread decline in sales of existing homes, with 21 of 28 metropolitan markets registering a drop from July, and 16 of the markets showing a fall off of five per cent or more.
As well, listings fell in 17 of the 28 markets, an indication that owners were reluctant to place their homes for sale due to the soft conditions.
Senior economist Robin Wiebe of the Conference Board said there was evidence of cooling in some markets -- particularly Vancouver and Victoria -- before the new rules went into effect July 9. But the new data shows the slowdown has spread to most markets and from coast to coast.
"When you see sales down in three-quarters of the market, that means it's pretty widespread," he said. "It's knocked down previously high-flying markets like Regina and Saskatoon down a peg. Vancouver had been showing signs of cooling, now it's spread out into the Fraser Valley."
When Finance Minister Jim Flaherty announced in July that the maximum amortization period for mortgage would be reduced to 25 years from 30 years, the government estimated it would increase monthly payments by $184 on a $350,000 mortgage.
It was the fourth time Flaherty tightened mortgage requirements in four years, but the measure was regarded as the one likely to be the most effective.
While sales and prices were only temporarily sidetracked by the previous announcements, only to recover a few months later, this might "be the one that broke the camel's back," said Wiebe.
Scotiabank economist Adrienne Warren said the cumulative impact of Flaherty's tightening measures are definitely showing up in the numbers, but other factors are playing a role, including buyer fatigue and high household debt, as well as concerns about the economy.
"We had been anticipating a slowdown, but these new mortgage rules reinforced the slowdown, particularly for first-time home buyers. (The rules) are making it harder for them to get into the market," she said.
Last week, the Canadian Real Estate Association reported that sales of existing homes fell 5.8 per cent in August from July, and were down 8.9 per cent from August 2011.
Still, the latest data shows that while sales and listings are down, prices appear to be holding steady.
The report found prices fell in only nine of the 28 markets in August from the previous month. Compared to last August, prices were up in 25 markets.
Economists have generally been forecasting a correction of between 10 and 25 per cent in prices over the next two or three years. Vancouver, which had for years been Canada's hottest market, has seen a tumble of about 30 per cent in resale homes.
But Wiebe is not so sure the correction will be as severe as many predict, or that Vancouver's market is as cold as the numbers suggest.
He notes that Vancouver's average home prices are skewed by the number of high-end property sold -- many to investors from China. Both the meteoric rise and current decline are "overstated," he said.
Homes in the Toronto area, Canada's largest market, are also likely to retain their value, he said, because the economy in the city remains healthy and the greater metropolitan area continues to experience strong population growth.